Active
Project:
JW Player Module for Drupal
Version:
6.x-1.1
Component:
Code
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Feature request
Assigned:
Unassigned
Reporter:
Created:
14 Feb 2011 at 07:29 UTC
Updated:
8 Nov 2011 at 12:11 UTC
Jump to comment: Most recent, Most recent file
Comments
Comment #1
JW Player commented@sergebw,
The port to Drupal 7 is definitely on the roadmap. We don't have an exact estimate yet as we're a bit short on resources at the moment.
Thanks.
Comment #2
jdwfly commentedNot sure how much this would help but I ran this through the automated upgrade tool. This would definitely be a first step in the right direction to port the module.
Comment #3
prashant.panigrahi commentedI am waiting for a drupal 7 update of JW player.
Comment #4
smith@lkpd.org commentedI am going to give up on this module.
They keep saying they are going to support it.
Nothing for over a year.
Must be something else out there.
Comment #5
JW Player commentedStarting next month we'll be updating the module to support HTML5, followed by an update to Drupal 7.
We have numerous other projects as well as development of the JW Player itself to manage. It's been a case of available resources which should be resolved next month.
I really do apologize for the inconvenience.
Comment #6
skilip commented@LongTail Video: A while ago I sent you a message on which Cameron Waeland replied. In that message I proposed merging work I did on a JW Player field module with this module. I've created a sandbox of my work so far so you can estimate wether or not our modules can be merged or not.
Comment #7
drublue commentedthe only single reason why I didn't move to Drupal 7 yet is that I can't use JW-Player yet. And the reason why I didn't buy a license yet because I can't put the player to productive use. I understand there are many things to do on the development side (even for the player itself) ...but all this has been on the "roadmap" for such a long time now...it would be fabulous to get a time estimate to be able to decide if I should abandon JWP or not.
Comment #8
JW Player commentedJust a quick update. Development has begun on the JW Player 5.6 and HTML5 support version of the module. This should be completed in the next week or two. After this we'll start setting our sights on the Drupal 7 port.
@skilip,
I'll take a look at the sandbox once the JW Player 5.6 update is completed.
Thanks.
Comment #9
rickvug commented@skilip I took a brief look at your D7 code and the implementation is excellent. JW Player should be a implemented as a file field formatter. I'm presently working as part of a development team that plans to tackle video in 2-3 weeks time. The roadmap is use JW Player or FlowPlayer as a field formatter on files uploaded via file field. In addition there are plans to use Media module for managing video assets and Media Gallery / Styles for creating mixed galleries of photos and videos. We'd like to use your work and contribute back to the community as much as possible. File handling is a very exciting space in D7 and JW Player could be a big part of the problem space.
@LongTail Video I recommend taking a look at skillip's code and the Media project sooner than later. Field API, File API, Stream Wrappers and the Media project are some of the largest changes in Drupal 7 and likely mean that it is time to take a fresh look at the JW Player module and how it fits into the picture.
Comment #10
SanFeda commentedstill waiting
Comment #11
rickvug commented@SanFeda If you have an immediate need checkout and test the sandbox at http://drupal.org/sandbox/skilip/1143300.
Comment #12
JW Player commentedNow that the HTML5 update has been released we'll be taking a deeper look at Drupal 7. We don't want to miss the boat. :)
We're interested in merging with skilip's field implementation so we'll be reviewing that sometime this week.
We certainly appreciate the level of interest you guys are showing.
Thanks.
Comment #13
caponey commentedneed this for D7 too, so subscribing.
I'm redeveloping a gaming site, and need a player with an age gate plugin, and as far as I'm concerned, this is the best option out there, period. Really appreciate the work, Long Tail!
Comment #14
viktor.mastoridis commentedJW on Drupal 7. Subscribing
Comment #15
michèle commented+1
Comment #16
Zachmo commentedsubscribing... Would love to see this asap :)
Comment #17
JW Player commentedJust to give you guys an update, I've started the process of porting although it seems like it will be fairly involved (just based on the activation errors I'm seeing). Hopefully I can give you a specific date soon.
Comment #18
rickvug commented@LongTail Video Thank you for the update. Have you taken a look at http://drupal.org/sandbox/skilip/1143300? It is a different approach but is much more in line with how most would like to use JW Player in D7 (my opinion of course but based on much experience). It could be worthwhile to start from this work rather than the D6 module.
Comment #19
Anonymous (not verified) commented@rickvug
Letting you know that yes, this is what seems to be the right direction. I dropped it in my personal sandbox and, aside from a little bit of buggy AJAX stuff on the upload, everything worked very, very nicely. Good work! I'll try and make some patches for the module (if necessary) as we are probably going to try and use this on a production site very soon.
Comment #20
JW Player commentedYeah, you guys are convincing me this is the right direction. :)
I'm very open to working with you guys on this. Just trying to figure out the details with my boss.
Comment #21
rickvug commented@LongTailVideo Glad that you're on board! I have commit access to the sandbox and should start making commits in the next week or so. Also see Lullabot's custom JW module for Videola at https://github.com/Lullabot/videola/tree/master/modules/custom/jwplayer. Lullabot's approach is very similar. I'd really like to merge all of this work together into a new "best of breed" JW Player module. I'd be happy to bring the work into this project, perhaps as a new branch. Alternately it could be worth starting fresh at drupal.org/project/jwplayer or drupal.org/project/jw_player. "jwplayermodule" a redundant namespace for a module so now would be a good time to change that. :)
Comment #22
JW Player commented@rickvug,
I believe I've been in contact with your associate via email. I'm going over the outline that he provided with my boss and we'll see what we need to do in order to move forward. Stay tuned.
Thanks.
Comment #23
richardmaheux commentedSubscribing
Comment #24
ccshannon commentedsubscribe
Comment #25
annikaC commentedSubscribing
Comment #26
VonZesen commentedSubscribing
Comment #27
tumbledown100 commentedSubscribing
Comment #28
annikaC commentedAny update from LongTail on this?
Comment #29
Anonymous (not verified) commentedI can't help but think this JWPlayer feature:
...almost deprecates this particular module (for someone that knows somewhat what they are doing anyways). Think about what you can do with just Views and a simple Video field!
Thoughts?
Comment #30
dsparrow commented@mpoplin would you care to elaborate how the new feature deprecates this module?
I need my users to be able to "create" new videos by uploading them and then we'll display them using JW Player. So I need a custom field type which is what this module seems to provide. How would you see and views solving this issue?
Comment #31
dilari commentedsubscribe
Comment #32
one-five commented@LongTailVideo got the v7 goods now? :)
Comment #33
mimrock commentedsubscribing
Comment #34
totocol commentedAny updates on this?
Would be great to see a D7 version being released soon!
Comment #35
Anonymous (not verified) commenteddsparrow,
If you just let the D7 file field handle the actual storage and retrieval of the videos, you can create a persistent Javascript file that formats the video data that Views provides when it sees the necessary JSON object hanging out in the document object (in my case anyways). In fact I just launched a site yesterday for an enormous client doing exactly that... I'd be glad to share the code I used to do this with too.
I realize that it doesn't make the module 'obsolete' in a strict sense because not everyone is a programmer (and I said that in my previous post) but an intermediate Drupal developer should not have a problem making JWPlayer work with a couple hours of tinkering.
Comment #36
Anonymous (not verified) commentedI'll go ahead and just post the Javascript that does all of the hard work. It assumes you have a JSON object with the video data already which I produced using a Views query and PHP's json_encode() function.
Comment #37
chefmungus commentedSubscribe
Comment #38
dsparrow commentedmpoplin,
In the end, we ended up using streaming which meant that I don't really need any custom code, just doing it all in Javascript.
Thanks though.
Comment #39
webmestre commentedSubscribing !
Comment #40
Refineo commentedsubscribe
Comment #41
Anonymous (not verified) commenteddsparrow,
Funny you mention that because the client changed their minds after launch and insisted on Brightcove streaming instead. Hey that's why we charge by the hour right? B)
Comment #42
dv8withn8 commentedThe company I'm with licensed JW player for some other projects and with some new D7 sites in the pipe, hoping this module gets ported fairly soon. Though, looks like @LongTail_Video has been dormant the last 2 months. Anyone know of another, field based, video solution?
Comment #43
rickvug commented@dv8withn8 Check out http://drupal.org/sandbox/skilip/1143300 for a D7 JW Player module that provides a field formatter and presets. More testers are welcome to iron out any bugs before made an official project with releases.
Comment #44
bryancasler commentedsubscribe
Comment #45
Dematron commented@rickvug there is an ajax error in the module working. Where should I post debug information?
Comment #46
rickvug commented@Dematron Please post as an issue against the sandbox module and I'll take a look soon. I hope to upgrade to a full project soon so additional testing like this is welcome!
Comment #47
rickvug commentedAll: for Drupal 7 please check out http://drupal.org/project/jw_player. The sandbox discussed above is now a full project with a dev tarball available. I've spoken to Long Trail in the past and there is no short term plan to port this project. If/when resources become available this may happen, but the port may just end up being enhancements to the new module to ensure feature parity with what is here now. (@LongTail Video, correct if wrong)
Please help move this new module towards a full release by testing, adding features requests and submitting patches. More feedback and help = a shorter time period to a solid release.
Comment #48
webmestre commentedVery good new !
Comment #49
annikaC commentedGreat work, thanks!
Comment #50
JW Player commentedYes, @rickvug is correct.
It's really a question of bandwidth on our end. Currently, my availability for Drupal development is limited to maintenance updates to our Drupal 6 module. However, this shouldn't always be the case and in the future it's our intent to work more closely with @rickvug to make an official fully featured module for Drupal 7 (The name of his module probably gives this away slightly :)).
Thanks.
Comment #51
rickvug commented@LongTail Video Happy to see that we're still on the same page. :) What do you think about updating the module description to point to http://drupal.org/project/jw_player for Drupal 7 and then marking this issue as either "fixed" or "postponed"?
Comment #52
ytsurktinymce WYSIWYG lib brings also a flash video player nicely integrated with IMCE