Closed (outdated)
Project:
Commerce PayPal
Version:
7.x-1.x-dev
Component:
PayPal WPP
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Feature request
Assigned:
Unassigned
Reporter:
Created:
14 Apr 2011 at 06:06 UTC
Updated:
18 Aug 2025 at 21:16 UTC
Jump to comment: Most recent
Comments
Comment #1
pixelsweatshop commentedsub
Comment #2
chrisroditis commentedsub
Comment #3
Anticosti commentedsub
Comment #4
dremy commented+1 Please integrate for auto billing
Comment #5
BenK commentedSubscribing
Comment #6
minnur commentedsubscribing
Comment #7
storyleader commentedsub
Comment #8
onsale002 commentedsub
Comment #9
onsale002 commented... sorry Duplicate :)
Comment #10
JGO commentedSubscribing for sure !
Comment #11
nate.dame commentedsubscribing
Comment #12
Anonymous (not verified) commentedsub
Comment #13
mrconnerton commentedsub
Comment #14
fagoSubscribing
Comment #15
pardalman commentedSubscribing too...
Comment #16
refreshingapathy commentedI guess I'll join the queue and subscribe :)
Comment #17
the_g_bomb commentedhttp://drupal.org/node/1041274#comment-5126658 seems to suggest paypal subscription integration already exists just not in this module, but in this one instead: http://drupal.org/project/commerce_subscription
Comment #18
carsonwsubscribing
Comment #19
josh waihi commentedSubscribe.
Subscription and recurring billing has to be implemented with the payment gateway.
Comment #20
ntigh52 commentedSubscribe.
Comment #21
rooby commented@ntigh52:
Check out the 'Follow' button at the top of issues.
Comment #22
ntigh52 commentedrooby,
I didnt understand what to do with the follow button?!
Comment #23
Robin Millette commentedUse the Follow button instead of "subscribing" with a comment. Less noise for us, same effect to you.
Comment #24
ntigh52 commentedI didnt know the Follow button before thanks.
Comment #25
aaronbaumanCouldn't WPP be leveraged to implement recurring payments with commerce_recurring?
Very different approach than commerce_subscription or commerce_sp / commerce_sp_paypal which use Recurring Billing Profiles.
Comment #26
rszrama commentedYep, it could - you can submit reference transactions for up to a year after an original transaction. This may not make it suited well for annual subscriptions, but it would be fine for monthly, semi-annual, etc. I just don't want to maintain that code along with the basic integration in here, but a third party module could build on the API in these modules to integrate with Recurring.
Comment #27
deggertsen commented@rszrama, so if I'm understanding correctly, Paypal will no longer accept recurring payments from a referenced transaction that is over a year old? Does it renew that year period each time a payment is processed, or does it look back to the original transaction. Would just like a bit of clarification here as I'm looking to potentially integrate with http://drupal.org/project/commerce_recurring 2.x.
Comment #28
rszrama commentedYep, it "renews." Really, what's happening is you just end up with a new transaction from which to make a follow-up reference transaction. If I understand it right, you'd have to use the reference transaction's transaction ID for the future reference - but it's worth discussing with PayPal support.
Comment #29
deggertsen commentedGood to know. I'm probably going to see if http://drupal.org/project/commerce_sp_paypal will work first, but if it doesn't work how I want it to I will see what I can do to integrate http://drupal.org/project/commerce_recurring.
Comment #30
rikki_iki commented@deggertsen did you make any progress with this?
Comment #31
deggertsen commented@rikki_iki Not yet. I actually think I may just go with commerce_sp_paypal as it seems to be working reasonably well. Still in the early testing phase, but I plan to spend much more time on this in the next few weeks.
Comment #32
kebz commentedAny thoughts on this for the new year?
I'm just looking for an easy way to create a subscription/payment program for new members BEFORE creating an account .. (pay beforehand... either monthly, biannually, yearly, etc)
Comment #33
ntigh52 commentedhttp://drupal.org/project/commerce_sp_paypal
And
https://www.drupal.org/project/commerce_sp
And
https://www.drupal.org/project/commerce_license
Comment #34
torgospizza@ntigh52: The two PayPal Subscription modules you reference are no longer supported.
Comment #35
deggertsen commentedCheck out Paypal Roles. It's new and I'm working on implementing it on a site I'm building right now. There seem to be a few bugs still, but for the most part it's working. This is not a full shopping cart solution, but for simple paypal subscriptions that grant a role it can work.
Comment #36
kebz commented@Deggertsen
Thank You! I'm going to install right now and see how it works with Drupal.
I've done my own subscription through PayPal... but it's done manually and I had to play around with PHP for the IPN portion.
I'm hoping yours does exactly what I'm looking for. I'll be back to report =)
Comment #37
nyleve101 commentedStumbled across a great article on how to implement recurring subscriptions with WPS here http://shushuinbar.blogspot.co.il/2013/04/paypal-subscription-and-recurr.... The rules are missing from the article but they can be found here https://gist.github.com/shushu?direction=asc&sort=created.
Comment #38
rooby commentedFrom what I can tell the solutions mentioned in previous comments are not supported anymore, except for the newer PayPal Roles, which from my quick look doesn't seem to solve the purpose of this issue.
I have updated the main description of this issue to properly describe what it is for.
Comment #39
metallized commentedsuscribe.
Comment #40
bjlewis2 commentedHey @metallized, there's a "Follow" button that you can use to receive updates instead of commenting. That helps keep the comments clean. :)
Comment #41
tomtech commentedAutomatically closed because Drupal 7 security and bugfix support has ended as of 5 January 2025. If the issue verifiably applies to later versions, please reopen with details and update the version.