Comments in forums

Same to me. In the subject field I see Re: [comment-parent-title-raw]. All other comment forms on the site works properly.

sorry guys for being away, and thanks for reporting this issue

I see Re: [comment-parent-title-raw].

that's not D7 syntax for tokens, branches must be mixed,
I'll try to find a break to review this,
if you think I'm taking too long, please contact me

BTW, this is all this version is about

Any news on this bug?

@SharonD214

This does not put in the subject of the original topic.

I tested with comment_subject-7.x-2.0-alpha1 and Drupal 7.4 and it does work in forums

It allows you to enter your own

yes, but it is configurable,
you may change the "Comment settings" of your Forum content type at admin/structure/types/manage/forum
and uncheck the option "Allow comment title"

but if left empty, uses the actual comment as the subject.

if left blank it is considered edited, and therefore the proposed subject was rejected/declined,
and then the behavior fallbacks to Drupal's default behavior, which is taking the first words from the body

to have it working as I think you want,
you should uncheck the checkbox "Allow comment title" so users won't be able to enter/modify the proposed subject
otherwise the subject will be presented to the user for modifications,
and if left as proposed, it should read "Re: my forum topic title"

@#1, #2

In the subject field I see Re: [comment-parent-title-raw].

I just downloaded comment_subject-7.x-2.0-alpha1 and I can't see how you got that [comment-parent-title-raw] part

are we talking about D7 ?

@SharonD214

This does not put in the subject of the original topic.

perhaps you are expecting that comments replying to comments take the title of the parent node as well (normally they will take the "parent's title" whether it is the node or another comment)

in that case, you might want flat comments http://drupal.org/project/flatcomments

@SharonD214, #7
if you don't want flat comments at all, then you simply change the pattern used to generate the comment's subject

go to admin/structure/types/manage/forum
and change the "Default title pattern"
to Re: [comment:node:title]

@#9 mmm... sounds like you have an issue, which I can't get to reproduce

I'll need more info about the versions you're using (Drupal and contrib modules)
and a detailed step by step to get that misbehavior in a fresh install

I am also using comment subjects 7.x-1.0-alpha2.

wait... you reported this issue for 7.x-2.0-aplha1
and that is the one I've been testing

did you want all of those as well?

I know they can be a bunch,
try to list the ones related with forums or comments

Also I am using Advanced forum 7.x-2.0 alpha1.

I'll give it a try ...soon I hope

I see nothing in the subject field. Module is enabled. Do I change some settings on other place?

D7.22 this module: 7.x-1.0-alpha2

Solved by installing 7.x-2.0-alpha2