This looks like a very interesting project!

I use Drupal 5.1 - are there any plans to make this project compatible with 5.1?

Comments

frjo’s picture

The HEAD version of the Vote up/down Package have been updated for Drupal 5 and need testing. Please submit any bugs and feature request through the projects issue tracker.

ron williams’s picture

The vote up/down packages goal was to create a digg/reddit like module for drupal. The 4.7 version worked quite well, however 5.x support has stagnated. The current issue comes in that the developer of voting api released a non working add-on to voting api which has the same function as voting actions. Due to this the following attempts to make voting actions work as seen at http://drupal.org/node/110896. These have failed to allow promotion/demotion to/from the front page. There have been numerous requests to have voting api's version updated, however this has not occurred; see http://drupal.org/node/107523.

Optional modules which need to be completed are the userpoints module. Nothing appears to have been updated since Feb. 19 for userpoints 2.0 which I am really interested in using.

Is there any chance frjo could throw in a hand to help the voting api/voting actions modules and possibly the userpoints modules?

frjo’s picture

This is a problem with a module that depends so mush on other modules. Userpoints is a nice addition but voting_actions in some form is essential to Vote up/down.

I have no time to work on these modules myself anytime soon so lets hope Eaton and Kbahey starts using Drupal 5 themselves :-).

ron williams’s picture

The topic at http://drupal.org/node/110896 has been updated. votingapi_actions is the direction which eaton with be going towards in regards to the voting actions module. He stated that he is working on this.

Ryanbach’s picture

Subscribing.

jackdaw’s picture

I see that Voting Actions is finally ready for Drupal 5.x

http://drupal.org/project/voting_actions
http://drupal.org/node/110896

So now the big question is: Has anybody had any luck with upgrading the Vote Up/Down package to Drupal 5.x ?

frjo’s picture

Thanks for the heads up on voting_actions.module! I will try to make some time soon to take a look at it.

As I have stated above the HEAD version of the Vote up/down Package have been updated for Drupal 5 and mostly works as far as I can tell.

frjo’s picture

I have tested Vote up/down HEAD with Actions v1.25.2.2 , Voting API v1.40.2.5 and Voting Actions v1.15.2.4 and it seems to work :-)!

I'm very interested to here from other people who has tested this.

madjr’s picture

Yes, they seem to work. However the HEAD version along with actions module has less features then v4.7 (like comments publish/unpublish is missing)

Promoting to frontpage and making sticky seems to work fine, but i can't get the actions "Award/deduct userpoint to node author (Vote up/down)" to work.

frjo’s picture

but i can't get the actions "Award/deduct userpoint to node author (Vote up/down)" to work.

I found a bug in vote_up_down_actions.inc yesterday so download the just released 5.x-1.x-dev where I have fixed it.

jackdaw’s picture

I've upgraded my from 4.7 to 5.1 now, and everything seems to work OK.

I had to reconfigure the configurations of some modules (voting actions, tagadelic, reactivate 'recent popular content' block in views), but other than that, it was pretty painless.

Thanks a lot !

frjo’s picture

Status: Active » Fixed

Good to here it's working well for you.

Anonymous’s picture

Status: Fixed » Closed (fixed)