I had up my permissions as follows

comment module anonymous logged in

access comments                       checked        checked
administer comments	               blank          blank
post comments                         checked        checked
post comments without approval        checked        checked

node modulecreate content type checked checked

And the anon_nodecreate settings to Do not allow anonymous node creation and set form error.

This was however preventing anonymous users of commenting - they received the above mentioned 'form error'.

I circumvented that limitation by checking Allow saving node anonymously when user details do not validate. instead, and in the general permissions to disallow anonymous users to create new nodes.

Not exactly intuitive, so when someone looks again at this module, maybe try to make it respect the core comment permissions.

But in any case it works way better there the in inline registration-module, #1552340: IR refuses anonymous comments.

Comments

eiland’s picture

eiland commented

So that was posted too quick, because with anonymous users disallowed to create nodes, they can get to the add/node screen.

Now I modified the anon_nodecreate.module on line 111

from
if($newuser_error && $existinguser_error && $donot_allow_anon == '1') {

to
if($newuser_error && $existinguser_error && $donot_allow_anon == '1' && arg(1)!="reply") {