Suppress "comment" link in "create content" (node/add) page

I know there is an example in the wild of another module that successfully did this. I'll ask around which it was, and you should hop into #drupal or #drupal-dev and ask there as well. Then we can study the approach taken and see how it applies to nodecomment. The good news is that the ability to do this is a new feature in Drupal 6 =)

Nodereview module does this like the following:

function nodereview_menu() {
  ....
    // Hide the normal node-add page, since we never want users to see it
    $items[] = array(
      'path' => 'node/add/nodereview',
      'access' => FALSE,
    );
  ...

Webchick, you rock!

You can apply your logic and webchick's code to hook_menu of nodecomment. Depending on the conditions you spelled out, return the array from webchick (in $items) with access either TRUE or FALSE. Please roll a patch and submit here so that we can add this as a feature to the module.

I think the proposed solution goes somewhere along the lines of "am I on node/add? If so return FALSE for the access to node/add/comment. Otherwise return TRUE". This can all be done in nodecomment_menu in the !$may_cache section.

Hi,
Any progress in this? I need to hide the comments on create content pages and for anonymous users it should only be possible to add comments to parent-nodes which are in the system.
Thanks you in advance for progress update!
Greetings,
Martijn

I am looking for a way to provide access control to the comments. This way the comments will be shown to users with a specific access or permissions level and not for others. Any ideas how can I do this?

Thanks

I ran into this problem moments after I installed this module. After I finish the current project I am on, I am going to try to find some time to find a non-core module-based way to do this. But, for now, I hacked the drupal-5.7/modules/node/node.module file in what I believe is a completely unobtrusive manner. This php file controls, among many other things, the list of content types that get generated when you go to node/add ("Create content"). The loop that generates the list checks that the type has a create access permission for the current user and a _form function. To this boolean statement I added "and if this type is not a comment". Now the content type will not show up for anyone and the "Add new comment" will show up in content viewings and the create form is accessible.

As much as I hate hacking core functionality, this is very small. Keeping a good record of revisions will help if we ever need to upgrade.

Enjoy. I think this tiny hack makes this otherwise great module just right. I'm really glad I didn't have to write the whole thing :)


--- node.module (revision 6)
+++ node.module (working copy)
@@ -2208,7 +2208,7 @@
else {
// If no (valid) node type has been provided, display a node type overview.
foreach ($types as $type) {
- if (function_exists($type->module .'_form') && node_access('create', $type->type)) {
+ if (function_exists($type->module .'_form') && node_access('create', $type->type) && $type->type != "comment") {
$type_url_str = str_replace('_', '-', $type->type);
$title = t('Add a new @s.', array('@s' => $type->name));


jason

I am a noob and all I did to accompolish taht was to disable that particular menu item.
:)
Any myusers are no drupal experts, to know the direct links

Hi,

I didn;t want to hack core. I use drupal 5, 7 august 1.dev version.
I tried webchicks method, but it didn't work. Still in node/add the nodecomment type could be add.
The link itself is node/add/comment, so this is what I added in function nodecomment_menu:

function nodecomment_menu($may_cache) {
  $items = array();

    // Hide the normal node-add page, since we never want users to see it
    $items[] = array(
      'path' => 'node/add/comment',
      'access' => FALSE,
    );

The whole function now looks like this:

function nodecomment_menu($may_cache) {
  $items = array();

    // Hide the normal node-add page, since we never want users to see it
    $items[] = array(
      'path' => 'node/add/comment',
      'access' => FALSE,
    );

  if ($may_cache) {
    $items[] = array(
      'path' => 'admin/settings/nodecomment',
      'title' => t('Comments'),
      'callback' => 'drupal_get_form',
      'callback arguments' => array('nodecomment_admin_settings'),
      'access' => user_access('administer comments'),
      'description' => t("Administer your site's comment settings."),
    );

  }
  else {
    if ((arg(0) == 'node') && is_numeric(arg(1)) && is_numeric(arg(2))) {
      $items[] = array(
        'path' => ('node/'. arg(1) .'/'. arg(2)),
        'title' => t('View'),
        'callback' => 'node_page',
        'type' => MENU_CALLBACK,
      );
    }
  }

  return $items;

But it didn't work...what did I do wrong please?

EDIT: what works a little is:

    // Hide the normal node-add page, since we never want users to see it
    $items[] = array(
      'path' => 'node/add/comment',
      'access' => user_access('administer comments'),
    );

But now I got the access denied page. What I would like is being able to tell the user this is not granted on this page...or better..get rid of the whole link node/add/comment on node/add page..

greetings,
Martijn

Hi drupalicasso,

Thanks a lot for this simple and effective solution :). Glad that there are more newbies out there that have trouble following the posts, and still manage to find easy solutions.

Good thread. How would you use this feature, where would you access this feature in Drupal 6 please?

Hi Bacteria Man,

Would this help?

if (arg(0) == "node" && arg(1) == "add" && arg(2) == "comment" && arg(3) == "") {
     $items[] = array(
        'path' => 'node/add/comment',
        'callback' => 'userreview_help',
        'callback arguments' => array('userreview_howto'),
        'title'    => t('How to Submit a Review'),
        'access'   => TRUE,
        'type'     => MENU_CALLBACK
      );
     }

Greetings,
Martijn

I think a reasonable way to handle this is to make a setting on the admin/content/node-type/x page for "Use this type exclusively for node comments", which we could then use to hook_menu_alter() the node/add/x item and disable access to it directly.

Actually disabling access is incorrect. Turning it into a MENU_CALLBACK and making sure it doesn't work without an argument works, however. This is now done in the 2.x branch.

sorry for opening this issue again... but it would be much better if i could choose (!) if i want to hide the creation link.

cause on the site i am building at the moment, there will be only 1 content type for users to post which will include all kinds of stuff...

--> and so the comment nodes and the initial posted nodes should be the same!

can you help me?

@drupalok your feature request is not very common and it would require a separate issue anyway. Closing this.