Just wondering if this project is going to be officially released?

Comments

ykyuen’s picture

The project review team states that BeansTag has duplicated functionalities as Meta Tags so they are not going to approve this. Could you leave a comment in the following issue and see if the team would review it again? thx.
http://drupal.org/node/1191490

kingfisher64’s picture

What about some of the following for a package name?

nodemeta
metadata
node_metadata (there's already context_metadata so I don't see why not).
metatags_complete
metadata_complete

or

better_than_other_metatags_modules - :)

ykyuen’s picture

Currently i have removed the package name.

maybe we could consider using "Meta tags" as the package name later as it is an existing package name used by the Node Words and the Meta Tags modules.

Let's see if BeansTag would be approved by the review team first~ =D

kingfisher64’s picture

BeansTag is not really descriptive of what the module does though. That's my only issue. Meta tags sounds great.

I think it's worth mentioning another benefit of using this on the project homepage is the feature that this mod centrally manages meta info from one single page (structure > beanstag). Other mods add them to each individual node which is fine but it's far quicker to add/edit meta info if it's on one page in a nice neat list, especially considering seo is a continueous process. Constantly having to revisit individual nodes to edit this info over time is going to waste a lot of time. Beanstag handles this considerably better than all other available mods.

kingfisher64’s picture

One other possiblity is to get the module bundled as a sub module of http://drupal.org/project/metatag.

The biggest reason this could work is most users will be using this module due to it being established, however not all users are going to want to manage the metadata from each individual node page.

Structure > beanstag page provides one page to provide precicely this. You might get better use out of your hard work this way? This also could be considered as going with the grain instead of against it as well.

ykyuen’s picture

I have added your description on the project homepage. thanks for that.

Currently i will not merge beanstag into meta tags as i think it is a standalone module. Let's see how the review is going first.

Thanks again for your effort. =D

ykyuen’s picture

Assigned: Unassigned » ykyuen
Status: Active » Needs review
kingfisher64’s picture

Status: Needs review » Closed (works as designed)
kingfisher64’s picture

Issue summary: View changes

wrong question for issue title