When a user posts a comment, there isn't a message that's displayed to them, they're just brought to where their comment was posted. It would be nice if they got a confirmation message at the top of the node as well.
This is a major issue when the user is able to post comments, but not view them (related issue), since they get absolutely no feedback for their posting. They are just brought back to the original node.
| Comment | File | Size | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| #5 | 187061.patch | 691 bytes | robloach |
| #4 | 187061.patch | 846 bytes | robloach |
| #2 | comment_message.patch | 689 bytes | robloach |
Comments
Comment #1
Anonymous (not verified) commentedMoving to version 7.
Comment #2
robloachWith this patch, when a user posts a message, they're presented with a message letting them know their comment has been posted.
This is beginning to be an issue on Drupal.org itself with the new caching system. When a user posts a comment, their comment doesn't display and they get no feedback until a minute or two later when their comment finally appears on the site. I think this is something that should be present in Drupal 6.x...
Comment #3
keith.smith commentedThis would be nice, but would break the 6.x string freeze. Bumping to 7.x.
Comment #4
robloachRerolled to HEAD and tested.
Comment #5
robloachForgot the line breaks.
Comment #6
pasqualleIsn't it the basic example of trigger module? I am not sure if we really need this message.
Comment #7
catchFeedback is good. If we have messages for nodes, we should have them for comments too. So +1 from me.
Comment #8
jpoesen commentedApplied against HEAD and tested. Works as advertised.
Comment #9
pasqualleComment #10
catchStill applies with offset. Not giving feedback from user interactions is a bug.
Comment #11
dries commentedCommitted to CVS HEAD.
If we want to make this a trigger, we should do so in a follow-up patch.
Thanks.
Comment #12
Anonymous (not verified) commentedAutomatically closed -- issue fixed for two weeks with no activity.