Incompatible with Revisioning module

No, haven't tried the two together.

Hi,

I'm having the same issue. Did you make any progress on this?

No I haven't tried the two together. Anyone else?

Revert appears here (with workbench_moderation enabled, but not on that node type), but I get permission denied.
also get it on revision view.

everything works fine when i disable workbench moderation.

the reason is probably hook_menu..
workbench moderation has a higher weight, and defines paths like node/%node/revision/%/, while revisioning shifts to node/%node/revision/%vid/. This confuses drupal and breaks the menu links, resulting in access denied with admin user.
I dont know what the best solution is, to patch the module(s) or not.. I am now testing a solution using a custom module that fixes the menu alternations and delegates both modules.

EDIT after some testing, dev en lots of headaches.. I've concluded both module cannot be made to be compatible with eachother without both of them doing architecture changes.

Thank you for your analysis, rv0!

There is little change of a major architectural change in Revisioning, I'm afraid.

Rik

Perhaps a notice about this incompatibility may be useful on the module page.

Well Revisioning came before Workbench so maybe it is more appropriate for them to put it on their page, don't you think?
Rik

Agreed
I'll ping-pong it over there then

Since it is still active I just wanted to confirm the incompatibility. With both modules on, there were no available actions in the "revisioning actions" section of the "Moderate" tab. I was unable to view, revert or delete previous revisions. When I turned off the Revisioning module, everything works like a charm.

With regards to #7 and #8, it would be very nice for other people who have the same problem to have a warning about the incompatibility on both the Revisioning project page as the Workbench moderation project page.

I'm wrestling with this one as well. I've tried disabling and unisntalling the revisioning module, but the only action that gets restored when I try this is view. Nobody can revert or delete from the workbench moderation UI, regardless of permissions.

Any advice on how to untangle this on a site where both have been enabled for a while would be much appreciated.

BBC: uninstall both, rebuild node access permissions?

Thanks rV0. I finally got to the bottom of this. It had to do with the fact that I had applied a patch (#13) from https://drupal.org/node/1233354. Once that change was reverted and the Revisioning module was disabled, revert and delete were available again.

I'll add a note over there too just in case it helps someone get to the bottom of that issue.

Any chance this conflict is resolved in the 2.x-dev release? I've been using Revisioning for years, and have sold the client on the benefits; however, now having to backtrack on that b/c we need WB moderation.

Never expected I'd have to choose between the two :(

Also, please remove the auto-population of "[authored by]" in moderation notes. Not useful and negates and chance of making it a required field to save revision.

I'm hopeful we can soon use Revisioning as it's always been, notes and all (trying to make it a required field too), and then gain the wonderful workflow benefits of WB moderation! Fingers crossed :)

Confirmed

As a newbie we've inherited a Drupal 7.39 project with revisioning. Of course we had all kind of access denied, mainly after publish action.

Out of draft and moderation, not saving node again. We tried patches as Access denied when viewing revisions that state has been changed without re-saving content [#1883556] | Drupal.org, which did half the job. Of course we checked ACL and other access modules, disable overlay... endless hours of reading too many patches, btw!

Now we desperately miss keep edits in same revisions of Revisioning, before actively change status, which of course didn't cope right with WM.

hi @Rotozaza

May you could try to migrate from " Workbench + Revisioning " To Workflow+Revisioning" ..

As Workbench is not yet ready .. Workflow integrate correctly with Revisioning Module.

.. I am still waiting for Workbench too.

thanks