Closed (outdated)
Project:
Drupal Open Learning
Component:
Documentation
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Task
Assigned:
Reporter:
Created:
18 Dec 2007 at 03:55 UTC
Updated:
14 May 2018 at 20:25 UTC
Jump to comment: Most recent, Most recent file
Comments
Comment #1
add1sun commentedWanted to link to the main page have about the compression/tech side of things: http://groups.drupal.org/node/2424
Other stuff we can standardize:
Screen resolution
Bumpers
Credits
Display license we release under (CC?)
Intro music?
Comment #2
gusaus commentedSome more random ideas/background regarding a format(s) and production guidelines for Drupal Dojo screencasts.
Requirements
Example Format
Ad model?
Examples and inspiration
See also
Comment #4
sdwrage commentedDivx Web Plugin would be a nice feature for the website because it would allow for high quality videos. Thats just my opinion though :)
Comment #5
add1sun commentedOK, I've got a very basic beginning list. People with more experience can expand upon this but I figured I'd get the ball rolling.
Requirements for premade videos submitted to the Drupal Dojo (many will apply to live screencast captures as well.)
Required:
- Final viewing format (mp4 and/or ogg?) -> what is the general feeling about offering multiple/minimal formats?
- Frame size (640x480, 800x600 maximum)
- Frame rate (10-15)
- Audio sampling (11.05 kHz - 22.05 kHz)
- Use multi-pass encoding
- Use the CC bumper at the end of the video (taken from http://wiki.creativecommons.org/images/8/8b/By-sa_bw.png and also available in the d.o handbook, http://drupal.org/node/62196)
- If you use music (e.g. for intro) make sure it can be released under CC. If in doubt, leave it out.
Timeline:
- Intro screen with video title on Dojo background (This is a random, basic branding idea. I've attached a *sample* to this issue. The bg image would be a standard Dojo image and then editors can add the white text over it for each video.)
- 15 seconds for creator/editor credits. If none, then add the premade Dojo credits. (Following the basic idea in the incentive thread.)
- The video
- 15 seconds again for creator/editor credits or Dojo credits.
- CC white text on black bumper (from list above.)
Nice to have but not required:
- Transcriptions
Tips:
- Use a script or notes to guide you. Do a dry run at least once, taking your time so you are comfortable with what you will be recording.
- Remove extra toolbars/status bar from your browser window
- Resize windows to eliminate any chrome you don't need (like address bar/toolbars in a browser or toolbars in other apps)
- If you make a mistake, pause then go back over the section and repeat. You can edit out the mistake later.
- On longer videos (> 10 minutes) make sure the material is broken into logical steps or sections. Create a brief index showing timestamps for the beginning of each section (not in/part of the video, but as a text list that can be supplied in the description on the node.) This way viewers can skip to the section they want.
Some other neat things to check out:
MAGpie (http://ncam.wgbh.org/webaccess/magpie/index.html)
Comment #6
Bence commentedSolutions for screen recording
Windows
Free solution: CamStudio
Recommended solution: Camtasia Studio 5 - $299, 30-day free trial available
Mac OS
Free solution: Built-in Mac tools
Recommended solution: iShowU - $20, 30-day free trial available
Linux
Free solution: xvidcap
Recommended solution: N/A - if you want to record screencasts, you can only use worse tools compared to Windows and Mac OS.
If you can afford to buy Camtasia Studio, I reccommend it. It offers the most functions and the easiest handling on the market.
Comment #7
add1sun commentedOk, if there is no other feedback this weekend, I'm going to finalize this list based on what we have here. We can start with this and then modify down the road as we see improvements to be made.
Comment #8
gusaus commentedThis has been submitted as a DROP task - please claim it over here:
http://drop.cwgordon.com/node/32
Comment #9
add1sun commentedChanging title to indicate the remaining issue of tips documentation.
The standard itself is pretty much done and we just need the "non-requirements" tips on making a good video stuff documented.
Comment #10
ghankstef commentedI've created a wiki page for this here: http://groups.drupal.org/node/8945. Feel free to edit. One question I've had is alot of this comes down to knowing how to use a screen capture and/or video editing app like say iShowU and iMovie for example. Making a tutorial for each set of potential apps is a fair amount of work. So I was thinking of pointing to documentation and tutorials for common apps. Thoughts?
Comment #11
BrightLoudNoise commentedFor OS X you should also look at ScreenFlow http://www.varasoftware.com/products/screenflow/ - Has really great callout functionality and a surprisingly powerful editing system for $99
Comment #12
add1sun commentedI'd never seen that before and it looks pretty darned slick. Unfortunately it crashed on me the two times I tried to use it and looking around on the web it seems like it is still quite buggy. Hopefully they can get it tightened up because it does look interesting.
Comment #13
add1sun commentedOh ghankstef, sorry I totally missed your question (bad me!) Yeah I would say keep the document generic and useful to anyone doing recording and then linking off to tuts on the specifics is great.
Comment #14
add1sun commentedthe wiki page is up on g.d.o
Comment #15
Anonymous (not verified) commentedAutomatically closed -- issue fixed for two weeks with no activity.
Comment #16
gusaus commentedComment #17
nimblevideo commentedTo really make a format like this viable for as wide of distribution possible, creating 22 minute shows would be ideal as that is the format used for 1/2 hour shows on broadcast television. 3 x 7 minute 20 second segments.
Comment #18
nimblevideo commentedComment #19
gusaus commented