We need to figure out what a standard Dojo video should be with very specific guidelines. Perhaps this will be two very similar specs, one for live casts and one for "packaged" vids? Once we have standards and get them written out we will make tasks to create videos to achieve them cross-platform but let's get this written out in text first.

CommentFileSizeAuthor
#5 dojo-slide.png66.5 KBadd1sun

Comments

add1sun’s picture

Wanted to link to the main page have about the compression/tech side of things: http://groups.drupal.org/node/2424

Other stuff we can standardize:
Screen resolution
Bumpers
Credits
Display license we release under (CC?)
Intro music?

gusaus’s picture

Some more random ideas/background regarding a format(s) and production guidelines for Drupal Dojo screencasts.

Requirements

  • Tighter, more streamlined lessons
    • Create outlines and scripts
    • Lessons that are 10 to 20 minutes rather than an hour and a half or more
    • A format for all of the sessions - something we can pitch to folks as an advertising opportunity
      • break a subject down into easy to handle segments
      • logical layout - Each lesson stands on its own, but builds on the previous lesson's knowledgebase
  • Fit the lessons into target-audience buckets:
    • Evaluator
    • Administrator
    • Designer/Themer
    • Developer
  • Higher production values
    • standardize screen-cap settings

Example Format

  • 20 minute segment
    • 10 logical segments
    • each ten part series should lead to the creation of a solution to a specific business problem

Ad model?

  • create the videos and put in blank ad spots
    • Advertise here with contact information
    • keep making videos until someone buys ads
  • go for a sponsor before you start
  • host the video and run an adsense block

Examples and inspiration



See also 

sdwrage’s picture

Category: task » feature

Divx Web Plugin would be a nice feature for the website because it would allow for high quality videos. Thats just my opinion though :)

add1sun’s picture

StatusFileSize
new66.5 KB

OK, I've got a very basic beginning list. People with more experience can expand upon this but I figured I'd get the ball rolling.

Requirements for premade videos submitted to the Drupal Dojo (many will apply to live screencast captures as well.)

Required:
- Final viewing format (mp4 and/or ogg?) -> what is the general feeling about offering multiple/minimal formats?
- Frame size (640x480, 800x600 maximum)
- Frame rate (10-15)
- Audio sampling (11.05 kHz - 22.05 kHz)
- Use multi-pass encoding
- Use the CC bumper at the end of the video (taken from http://wiki.creativecommons.org/images/8/8b/By-sa_bw.png and also available in the d.o handbook, http://drupal.org/node/62196)
- If you use music (e.g. for intro) make sure it can be released under CC. If in doubt, leave it out.

Timeline:
- Intro screen with video title on Dojo background (This is a random, basic branding idea. I've attached a *sample* to this issue. The bg image would be a standard Dojo image and then editors can add the white text over it for each video.)
- 15 seconds for creator/editor credits. If none, then add the premade Dojo credits. (Following the basic idea in the incentive thread.)
- The video
- 15 seconds again for creator/editor credits or Dojo credits.
- CC white text on black bumper (from list above.)

Nice to have but not required:
- Transcriptions

Tips:
- Use a script or notes to guide you. Do a dry run at least once, taking your time so you are comfortable with what you will be recording.
- Remove extra toolbars/status bar from your browser window
- Resize windows to eliminate any chrome you don't need (like address bar/toolbars in a browser or toolbars in other apps)
- If you make a mistake, pause then go back over the section and repeat. You can edit out the mistake later.
- On longer videos (> 10 minutes) make sure the material is broken into logical steps or sections. Create a brief index showing timestamps for the beginning of each section (not in/part of the video, but as a text list that can be supplied in the description on the node.) This way viewers can skip to the section they want.

Some other neat things to check out:
MAGpie (http://ncam.wgbh.org/webaccess/magpie/index.html)

Bence’s picture

For premade videos

Solutions for screen recording

Windows

Free solution: CamStudio
Recommended solution: Camtasia Studio 5 - $299, 30-day free trial available

Mac OS

Free solution: Built-in Mac tools
Recommended solution: iShowU - $20, 30-day free trial available

Linux

Free solution: xvidcap
Recommended solution: N/A - if you want to record screencasts, you can only use worse tools compared to Windows and Mac OS.

If you can afford to buy Camtasia Studio, I reccommend it. It offers the most functions and the easiest handling on the market.

  • Important things:
    • Plan exactly what to say and what to do. This is a very impotant step, as you can not stop while recording. It is highly recommended to prepare an outline you can rely on during the recording process and to consider it thoroughly before recording.
    • Check the volume of your microphone. You can do this by opening the volume control or the Camtasia Studio recording tool. Then start to speak at normal volume into the microphone. If the volume indicator goes half way up than it is ok. You can also check this by making a test recording.
    • You should avoid background noises. Make a test recording while the microphone is on but say nothing. Then play the recording while turning the speaker volume to the maximum. It is optimal if you can not hear any background noise. The cheapest microphone probably won’t meet your expectations.
    • Exit every unnecessarily running programs! Especially messengers like Skype, MSN, as they can disturb the quality and process of recording. Switch off even your mobile phone. Finally let the people around you know not to disturb.
    • Clean up your desktop, do not show unnecessary icons and programs.
  • As for the video, a resolultion of 800x600 is highly recommended. 800x600 ensures the ratio of 4:3, and resizing the video is easier. And the text is the most readable on 800x600.
  • Don’t move the windows of the programs too much! Set the needed programs (browser, text editor etc.) at an exact position before recording to avoid unnecessary movements. These can be very disturbing for the viewer. If the recorded program contains horizontal scroll bar (like the browser), then scroll only in case of real need. So try to minimize horizontal moving.
  • Record only the required part of the screen. In most cases the browser is recorded with Drupal running within. Therefore it is recommended to install Firefox, and then to download Web Developer addon to it. This addon can resize the Firefox window (800x600 is recommended. Therefore only the required part of the browser is recorded).
  • Set the font anti-aliasing in your operating system. If it is not set fonts appear badly.
  • Use clearly visible cursor when recording.
  • The speed of the cursor should not be too fast as it can be disturbing. You can set the speed in the control panel. Do not move the cursor too fast or unnecessary when recording and do not click too much either.
  • Wait 3 seconds before speaking when recording has started. Wait 3 seconds in the same way before you finish recording. Therefore nothing will be missing at the beginning and at the end.
add1sun’s picture

Status: Active » Needs review

Ok, if there is no other feedback this weekend, I'm going to finalize this list based on what we have here. We can start with this and then modify down the road as we see improvements to be made.

gusaus’s picture

Title: Create Dojo video "standard" » DROP task: Create Dojo video "standard"

This has been submitted as a DROP task - please claim it over here:
http://drop.cwgordon.com/node/32

add1sun’s picture

Title: DROP task: Create Dojo video "standard" » DROP task: Document recording video tips and tricks

Changing title to indicate the remaining issue of tips documentation.

The standard itself is pretty much done and we just need the "non-requirements" tips on making a good video stuff documented.

ghankstef’s picture

Category: feature » task

I've created a wiki page for this here: http://groups.drupal.org/node/8945. Feel free to edit. One question I've had is alot of this comes down to knowing how to use a screen capture and/or video editing app like say iShowU and iMovie for example. Making a tutorial for each set of potential apps is a fair amount of work. So I was thinking of pointing to documentation and tutorials for common apps. Thoughts?

BrightLoudNoise’s picture

For OS X you should also look at ScreenFlow http://www.varasoftware.com/products/screenflow/ - Has really great callout functionality and a surprisingly powerful editing system for $99

add1sun’s picture

I'd never seen that before and it looks pretty darned slick. Unfortunately it crashed on me the two times I tried to use it and looking around on the web it seems like it is still quite buggy. Hopefully they can get it tightened up because it does look interesting.

add1sun’s picture

Oh ghankstef, sorry I totally missed your question (bad me!) Yeah I would say keep the document generic and useful to anyone doing recording and then linking off to tuts on the specifics is great.

add1sun’s picture

Status: Needs review » Fixed

the wiki page is up on g.d.o

Anonymous’s picture

Status: Fixed » Closed (fixed)

Automatically closed -- issue fixed for two weeks with no activity.

gusaus’s picture

Title: DROP task: Document recording video tips and tricks » Production guidelines for educational videos
Status: Closed (fixed) » Needs work
nimblevideo’s picture

To really make a format like this viable for as wide of distribution possible, creating 22 minute shows would be ideal as that is the format used for 1/2 hour shows on broadcast television. 3 x 7 minute 20 second segments.

nimblevideo’s picture

Assigned: Unassigned » nimblevideo
gusaus’s picture

Issue summary: View changes
Status: Needs work » Closed (outdated)