Audio: 5.x-1.x-dev, also tried 5.x.1.3 before the dev. version.
GetID3: 1.7.7, also tried 1.7.8b2
ID3tag on files: tried both v1 and v2
TagEditor: EasyTag 2.0
Drupal 5.5 (soon 5.6)
PHP: PHP5
Tried different versions of the modules, but I cannot get the ID3 tags right. They are simply not present after the import.
Audio File Info is ok, it's just the tags.
Can someone please lead me in the right direction? Plz.
Should I try audio 5.x-2.x-dev?
/FAF
Comments
Comment #1
FAF commentedI also tried switching off Open BaseDir, made no difference.
Comment #2
FAF commentedInstalled 5.x-2.x-dev and Token, messing with them now.
So.... I will try to get the 5.x-2.x-dev and Token to work as they should.
Comment #3
FAF commentedOK..
MP3's are OK when imported, it's just OGG which gives me a hard time.
Audio, getid3, and so on, works as they should.
The issue is solved, I will try another editor for the OGG content.
Thx for your time.
/FAF
PS. FYI: I'm now runing audio-5.x-2.x-dev and token-5.x-1.9.
Comment #4
FAF commentedJust tested different OGG files, but cannot import the ID3 tags from OGG files?
Tried to go default on the audio settings, just to clean things up.
Anyone having problems with OGG and ID3 tags?
Comment #5
FAF commentedI think there is a problem with PHP 5.2.3, Getid3 and OGG tags.
There's nothing in the logs, no errors from getid3, only a statement that it has imported an OGG file.
I'm not running in safe mode, since that will create problems with OGG tags, so that is turned off.
Open BaseDir off makes no differens.
iconv is enabled in PHP, with iconv.input_encoding ISO-8859-1 on all, no problems there.
In PHP, I have tried to turn off the "disable_functions" argument, but it didn't help. Removed shell_exec though.
Also tried switching between Getid3 1.7.7 and 1.7.8b2, that didn't do it either.
MP3 file-tags work, but not OGG files....
Anyone have a clue? (or just a small one, plz)
Anyone with PHP 5.2.3 who has a problem with Getid3 and OGG?
I strongly believe that it's PHP 5.2.3 related, or maybe Token. Living in the dark here.
Thx.
Comment #6
drewish commentedbetter title since this seems ogg specific. you've mentioned a bunch of different versions of software but it's not clear if you ever had it working. i'll say straight out that since there's no flash plyer ogg isn't very well supported.
Comment #7
FAF commentedThank you for your answer.
Well, I suppose it's an ogg specific question, since mp3 works ok :). I don't use the flash player, never has. I just rename the player folder so that "click to play" shows up in the nodes. Looks more clean.
OGG worked for me, from Drupal version 4.7-5.2, also with the Audio module 1.3 and earlier, GetID3 1.7.7 worked too, but somehow, maybe during an upgrade, the import started to exclude the tags of the ogg files. I don't remember exactly when, but I think it was during the PHP upgrade from 4.* to 5*. Didn't check the import at that time, I just confirmed that the site was running and users could play the files.
I tightened up the security in the same procedure, open base dir on all the sites, added some restrictions in "disable_functions" under PHP5.
I will try to see if I can upgrade to PHP 5.2.5, need to make some research first. Maybe it's an 5.2.3 issue, don't know, but it's worth the try.
Been thinking of migrating to mp3, but I already have done allot of work converting to ogg, and ogg is free too. If I was to go for mp3, it would be exiting to test it on the new build of Drupal v.6. I would still need to downscale all my 128kbit mp3s to 64 kbit, as it's an educational on-demand lecturing site.
Is there any work in progress on Audio module for Drupal 6? If not, theres really no sense in changing to v6, and I can start to batch convert those MP3s.
Thank you for your reply :)
/FAF
Comment #8
FAF commentedUpgrading to PHP 5.2.5 didn't change anything, same issue with ogg.
I will convert to mp3, since its the format of choice, or the most widely supported format.
It would be nice though, if ogg was supported in the future, but then again, it would require a good amount of time from your side, better work on making the module bug-free and mainly support mp3, than spend the time on ogg and other formats.
I'll stick with Drupal 5.* and Audio-5.x-2.x-dev for now.
Thank you for the module and the time you spend on it.
/FAF