I followed the installation instructions to a T; can't figure out exactly what's wrong.
Basically, the module functions fine if I set "Location of comment submission form" to display below post or comments in admin/settings/nodecomment , but if I set it to "display on separate page" i get a page not found error when I click the "add comment" link.

Anyone have hints on how to diagnose this problem? I'm thinking this has something to do with the template file not being found (I have the theme file appropriately named and dropped in the proper directory)- maybe the fact that I have contemplate installed is causing an issue?

any help is appreciated

Comments

crea’s picture

crea commented
Status: Active » Closed (fixed)

D5 branch is not supported anymore. Closing.
Please reopen if the issue is relevant with Nodecomment 6.x-2 branch.

hackwater’s picture

hackwater commented

I know the D5 branch is no longer supported, but I felt it unfriendly (community-wise) to not post if I have an answer to the original question.

The short answer: themesettings module is not compatible with nodecomment, at least in D5.

Given that D5 is no longer supported, no big deal, but as it turns out, themesettings hijacks and rewrites the $links variable. I imagine any module that assumes that core comments is enabled would have similar effects. No idea if this affects D6 (or D7); I don't have a suitable test environment for this scenario.