Closed (fixed)
Project:
Drupal core
Component:
other
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Feature request
Assigned:
Unassigned
Reporter:
Created:
25 Jul 2005 at 11:40 UTC
Updated:
9 Oct 2005 at 16:20 UTC
Jump to comment: Most recent file
image_get_info() return information about image - width, height, extension, mime type.
It's quite common to get file size (physical size) when getting dimension.
This simple patch adds file_size to the returned array that contains file's size in bytes.
| Comment | File | Size | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| #5 | image.inc_0.diff | 1.14 KB | ezheidtmann |
| image.inc.diff | 1.14 KB | Cvbge |
Comments
Comment #1
Bèr Kessels commented+1 for this feature. But we should be carefull with it, though. This function is called an awful lot. Cvbe, have you got experience with benchmarking? I am interested to see if this has an impact on speed and performance.
If so, we could consider a lower level (inside the function) "caching": just see if the file exists in the file table, if so return those functions.
But let's not keep that from including this filesize.
Comment #2
Cvbge commentedI have no experience in benchmarking, I also have no real site that I could benchmark. If someone provides me with instructions and means for benchmarking I could do some tests.
The PHP documentation for filesize says:
grep shows that clearcache() is not used in drupal, so the cache is there. But the cache can only help in case you check the same file multiple times.
The real question is how often you do image_get_info() but are not interested in file size and is filesize() expensive or not.
Comment #3
ezheidtmann commentedI have not done a benchmark, but I would guess stat-ing a file is much less expensive then opening it up, parsing the file structure, and figuring out the dimensions.
Comment #4
ezheidtmann commentedimage_get_info() already calls is_file(), which does a stat() and caches the result. If my understanding is correct, that means the call to filesize() will hit the cache and thus have the minimum possible performance impact.
Comment #5
ezheidtmann commentedHere's an updated patch correcting a spelling error.
Comment #6
Bèr Kessels commentedplease do not get my comment as a "I do not lke it" :) I was merely wondering if this was going to have an impact on operformance.
But from what I see now, the PHP cache will save the day. But... does that cache live on forever? Or only for one PHP run?
Comment #7
ezheidtmann commentedI'm sorry if my comments seemed caustic. I was merely being frank.
The clearstatcache() doc page seems to imply that the PHP cache only lives for one page. But adding filesize() to image_get_info() would not change performance, as a stat() is already run for is_file(). Now, would removing is_file() help performance? I can't say.
Comment #8
Cvbge commentedNew flags ;)
Comment #9
dries commentedCommitted to HEAD.
Comment #10
(not verified) commentedComment #11
ken123 commentedComment #12
(not verified) commentedComment #13
(not verified) commentedComment #14
(not verified) commented