Comment Page 6.x-1.1 not working? [#299933]

Installed and tested on two different scenarios:

Major bug on a fresh install of Drupal 6.4 with Comment Page 6.x-1.1
Working great on Drupal 5.10 with Comment Page 5.x-1.1 but after upgrade to Drupal 6.4 with Comment Page 6.x-1.1, the same problem as above occurs.

The problem: All comment pages go to just one comment page - the first published comment. The url on the address bar is correct, but the page is still the first published comment. This occurs on all comment page links, may it be configured with url
.../comment/* or .../comment/*/node-title. All the same.

Comments

Comment #1

mryoung commented 11 September 2008 at 17:25

My problem is a bit different ... but comment_page still not working

I've got the link to the comment page on the comments ... but:
/comment/x <= not found 404

Any idea ?

Comment #2

daspit commented 21 September 2008 at 11:23

Status:

Active

» Needs review

I find and fix this bug.
it is in "function comment_page_display($comment_id)" in file comment_page.module -
variable $comment_id is not cid in Drupal 6

I change "$comment = _comment_load($comment_id);" at line 174
to "$comment = _comment_load($comment_id->cid);"
and all work fine

you can see how it is work now at:
http://dig.by/comment/4 and
http://dig.by/comment/3

Comment #3

johnnoc

Norwegian Bokmål

Oslo

commented 25 September 2008 at 03:04

#2 worked for me.

Comment #4

daspit commented 27 September 2008 at 06:41

I am not a PHP or CVS guru. My knowlege of PHP is "How to make Hello-Word application".

If my patch work fine, maybe anyone add it to new release?

Comment #5

alexmarkley commented 29 October 2008 at 21:31

I'm using Drupal 6.6, and I'm definitely experiencing this bug. All linked comment pages show up as "404 - page not found" instead of displaying any actual content.

The suggested patch at #2 seems to solve the problem. Any chance we could get a patched release?