Hi.

First of all, THANKS A LOT FOR THIS MODULE. In my opinion it should be in core's defaults modules.

I'm not sure but I think I've found a bug or maybe you could consider it like a feature request:

When I have no comments in a node and I go to the talk page I don't see any link to create a new comment. But when there is a comment I can see that link.

You can allways create the first comment from the "view" page itselft but I think it would be more user friendly if you can also create the first comment from the "talk" page and you have the option to define a "no comments yet" default message for "talk" page.

Kind regards and thanks in advance.

Comments

jeffschuler’s picture

jeffschuler
Location Boulder, Colorado
commented

In order for it to appear on the Talk page when no comments exist, the comment submission form needs to be displayed below post or comments as opposed to on a separate page.

This setting can be found in: Administer -> Content management -> Comments in the Post Settings section.

NoRandom’s picture

NoRandom commented

Thanks, it worked.

But now I have another problem (not so important as the first one): http://pixelgordo.com/node/107/talk#comment-50

When a comment already exist you get two different links to create a comment:

1.- The first one in a button below the comment form.

2.- The second one as plain text link at the bottom.

The problem is the text link doesn't have special css markup for hidding it.

Kind regards.

greggles’s picture

greggles
he/him
Primary language English
Location Denver, Colorado, USA
commented
Status: Active » Closed (duplicate)

A lot of these bugs were fixed in #517988: Three bugs with "Add new comment" link when comment form is set to "display on separate page" - perhaps you could try upgrading and see if that works? It's about time to upgrade to 6.x anyway ;)