Fresh installation of latest drupal 6.9, only core module
Ajax module installed
Comment settings -
preview : optional
Location of comment submission form: Display below post or comments
All permissions set properly

Newly posted comment does not show up though the url in address box changes -
comment only seen after page is manually refreshed.

Tested in Firefox , Opera , and IE6

CommentFileSizeAuthor
#16 screen.jpg43.28 KBmvvershinin

Comments

brendoncrawford’s picture

brendoncrawford commented
Assigned: Unassigned » brendoncrawford
Category: bug » feature
Priority: Normal » Minor

Thanks for your feedback. I will have a look.

misty3’s picture

misty3 commented

Could you reproduce this error ? A fresh install with only core modules or without any extra module can possibly demonstrate this. This makes ajax not usable by members.

With some modules like 'Watcher' (lightwieight subscription easy module) which has ajax options like "click to enable subscription" Ajax breaks normal operation in the sense that buttons like ""click to enable subscription" remain the same even after clicking when normally it would show "click to disable subscription"

brendoncrawford’s picture

brendoncrawford commented

Misty3,

I am not able to reproduce this bug. Here are the steps I took:

1) Go to node page
2) Click "add comment"
3) Input comment subject and body
4) Click "Submit"
5) Page redirects to node page

Are you having the same results? If so, what about this would be considered unexpected or buggy?

Thanks,
brendon

misty3’s picture

misty3 commented

I am sorry - are you using Drupal 6.9 ?
If so please set the following for the node type that is being commented:

Comment settings -
preview : optional
Location of comment submission form: Display below post or comments

Now when you or any user want to add comment they need not click any link ( suppose this is the use case) - they just read the node and fill up the comment form below the node content.

Now when they hit submit the url in the browser address box changes showing that there has been indeed addition of the comment but however the page does not refresh, thus not showing the comment.

Either the user keeps wondering what happened to his comment or sees this comment if he refreshes the page manually or revisits the page at a later time.

If you are unable to see this on localhost or actual site I will try to set up a test site to show this.

brendoncrawford’s picture

brendoncrawford commented
Category: feature » bug
Priority: Minor » Normal
Status: Active » Fixed

This has been fixed in 6.x-1.x-dev. Please allow up to 12 hours for dev package to update.

Thanks,
brendon

Status: Fixed » Closed (fixed)

Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.

kruser’s picture

kruser commented
Version: 6.x-1.12 » 6.x-1.x-dev
Status: Closed (fixed) » Active

This bug still exists - d6.16 with Disable Redirect enabled.

netboss’s picture

netboss commented

Same problem here, using d6.16. The comment preview doesn't properly work, it's not showing up the comment for preview, neither it's giving the user any feedback when the comment is saved (submitted). However, the comment is correctly being sent to the comment approval queue for anonymous users.

~!v@n

gausarts’s picture

gausarts commented

Subscribing. Thanks

ceerwk’s picture

ceerwk commented

Subscribing

dax444’s picture

dax444 commented

Didn't anyone sort this out? I am having the same issue. I type in a comment and click submit. The page slides back to the top of the page but does not show my new comment. If I hit refresh on the whole page the comment appears. It looks as if the AJAX is not refreshing the comment node though it is storing the comment.

Any suggestions?

Rick

thrash632’s picture

thrash632 commented
Priority: Normal » Major

I too am having this exact issue. Frustrating. This is a pretty bad bug.

Also like to point out that this occurs with the latest release of Drupal as well (6.19).

Bilmar’s picture

Bilmar commented

Is this still an issue with the latest version?
I am thinking of using nodecomment module with Ajax module but want to have the comment show on the page right after submitting.

Anonymous’s picture

Anonymous (not verified) commented

i' having the same issue with the latest recommended releases of drupal and ajax...

i need the possibility to comment a video while watching it badly. its working fine by using http://drupal.org/project/ajax_comments but there are some problems with the panels page template overwrite.

kundu’s picture

kundu commented

Subscribing

mvvershinin’s picture

mvvershinin commented
StatusFileSize
new screen.jpg43.28 KB

if you using module "AJAX"? try to go "yoursite/admin/settings/ajax" and disable all near "Comment Form". It helped me.
Sorry for my English.

janis_lv’s picture

janis_lv commented

subscribing

brendoncrawford’s picture

brendoncrawford commented
Status: Active » Needs work