Posted by -Shaman- on March 5, 2009 at 10:33pm
| Project: | AJAX Comments |
| Version: | 6.x-1.x-dev |
| Component: | Code |
| Category: | bug report |
| Priority: | critical |
| Assigned: | Unassigned |
| Status: | active |
Issue Summary
I noticed that there's no refresh after quoting reply, and another thing is that can't quote first post from the forum's thread.
Hope this will be solved, since quoting is an important thing ;-)
Thanx 4 gr8 module!
Comments
#1
#2
Issue above is about version (1.1.2.22), but I noticed that in newest dev. version (1.1.2.27) quoting completely doesn't works! That's why I changed priority from normal to critical.
#3
Quote support restored with latest commit to DEV version. The package with this code will be available in few hours. Here's tarball for you for testing if release will be late.
#4
In this version when I want quote first post in thread nothing happens, and when I want quote comment, the loading animation appears and that's all :(
#5
Could you please describe step-by-step reproduce actions?
#6
What do You mean?
#7
I mean, what do you do to make this bug? I'm testing it at my test intallation with garland+ajax_comments+quote and everything seems to works fine except some minore glitches. So please, describe me how to reproduce it, or record a little screenscast (some people done it before, just guessing) or something else. I just can't reproduce it.
#8
I also have testing site, default theme, and with newest versions of both modules ajax_comments 6.x-1.x-dev 1.1.2.29, and quote (6.x-1.1-beta2) I'm getting results as posted above.
#9
Just for you, my friend:
1. I installed a fresh drupal6.10, checked out a fresh dev release of ajax_comments (1.1.2.29), installed latest Quote (6.x-1.1-beta2)
2. Enabled "comment form after comments thread" options for Page content type.
3. Enabled Quote for Page content type.
4. Created a test node of Page content type. Visited this node. It contains a Quote link in it's links array and expanded main comments form (ajaxified).
5. When I pressing Quote link this time, the form is collapsing (yes, it is a bug), but if you open it by clicking form title, it actually contains the quote, so need to fix only initial collapsing when form expanded.
6. Trying to preview the quote - Works fine (save button appears). Saving - comment appears.
7. Missing Quote link in a new comment (it's a drupal's bug).
8. Refresh the page.
9. Press Quote link in the first comment - Works fine, comment form opens under the comment with a quote filled in.
10. Trying to preview the quote - Works fine (save button appears). Saving - comment appears.
11. Right after it, pressing the node's Quote link. It works fine - main comment form opens with quote filled in.
12. Trying to preview the quote - Works fine (save button appears). Saving - comment appears.
13. Posting 10 dummy comments in a row. Refreshing the page.
14. Pressing main Quote link - The page scrolls down, but form is collapsed (see 5.), but scroll works fine, so this test passed.
This I call step-by-step reproduce actions. And let's see what did you wrote:
> when I want quote first post in thread nothing happens
Well, it might be either related to (5) or be anything else, the description isn't clear enough.
>and when I want quote comment, the loading animation appears and that's all"
And this isn't reproducing at all in my steps.
I understand that testing and describing your actions might take some time, but, hell, it helps to trace bugs very much. And it's only up to you to give this help. The less feedback you give—the less I have time to fix everything up.
#10
With newest dev. it seems to be working back ok.
#11
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.
#12
Unfortunately, the problem persists with 6.x-1.x-dev. After clicking on quote link the progress bar appears and it is stuck there forever.