Possible duplication with nodereference_autocreate

They are different. This module combines the autocomplete functionality with the ability to create nodes that don't exist. Nodereference_autocreate can create new nodes, but it cannot reference existing ones.

I feel like this module will get a lot of similar questions, so I'm dedicating this one to nodereference_autocreate.

Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.

Nodereference_autocreate can create new nodes, but it cannot reference existing ones

I'm sorry, but that quote begs the question: Doesn't Node reference itself refer to existing nodes, meaning that you don't need an addon for that?

The normal workflow with a 'create-node-on-the-fly' module available:

1. Content type A has a node reference field associated with Content type B.
2. I create a new node of type A, add relevant data and reach the node reference field. Either of two things can happen.

a) the node I need to refer to is already existing, I select it and move on (this happens either via 'select list' option or 'autocomplete' option of the normal node reference field).
b) the node I need to refer to does not exist, I create the node of Content type B on the fly using either of the two modules in question.

3. I finish creating the original node of type A.

This leads to me repeating the question: What is the difference between the two modules.

(note: I'm not biased towards either of them, I'm really and truly wondering which one of them to use for my own project).

thanks
Elfur

To follow up on my own comment. There's a thread over at Autocreate Node Reference that gives an idea of what the difference is.

As I understand it, the other one deals with automatic creation of template-clones based on given criteria setup by the admin, while this module deals with automatic creation of a node (with a reference to the original one, setup by the user) that would be in a select list of a "normal" node reference field, had it been created earlier.

Is this a correct understanding?
If so, I suggest that the authors of both modules coordinate their comments and explanations and redirect users between them accordingly - because, then there's quite a difference between the two.

@elfur: Your understanding seems fine. Thank you for investigating the similarities and noting them here.

The differences of these two modules is also discussed in another issue for nodereference_autocreate: #494556: choose to create a new node or a created one.