The admin header does quite some duplication: the tabs sometimes appear in the node form area, sometimes in the D7UX tabs area. This is how it looks when you edit a node:

And it looks like this when you add a node:

The meta information tab is not always in the same place.
While it might make sense to distribute the tabs between "the node form" (first screenshot) and "the tab area" (Screenshot 2) this needs a clear concept.

I presume it is not easy to hijack tabs from the theme and display them in the header. Even more so as this has to make assumptions about the main theme of the site: If someone does not implement tabs in a stardard way, the admin header is screwed and can't be blamed.

Other links affected: The "add content" link which is normally in what we sometimes call "User Menu" and is found in the Video as "Manage".
If the "add" link is in the header, it should not be duplicated in the "theme area".

I guess there is more trouble like this that I have not found yet. How about using this issue for collecting these and splitting up into seperate issues if needed.

Comments

gábor hojtsy’s picture

Status: Active » Postponed

The management menu / create content issue is at #511258: Do not enable the management menu by default and it has a nicely working patch except that if we remove the management menu, people will not have a way to add content if they don't see the admin menu. So content creation needs to move out of that menu.

The Content / Meta tabs are only appearing in the Google repository and do not apply yet to Drupal core, since it does not have these horizontal tabs committed at all. See #472126: D7UX: Move buttons to right area, add content and meta selector. We are aware of this issue, and the pattern is that when you use the overlay, it is already aware of the horizontal tabs, but the admin theme is not yet (and we did not figure out how to resolve the tabs on the navigation and the horizontal tabs appearing at the same time). Since horizontal tabs are not in core yet, this problem should be solved by whatever component gets in later, since that will expose this issue. At the moment, neither the theme, neither the overlay, neither the horizontal tabs are not in core. Postponing on when we'll face this issue.

casey’s picture

Component: admin.module » toolbar.module
David_Rothstein’s picture

Status: Postponed » Closed (duplicate)

As far as I can tell, the only remaining issues here are duplicates of #511258: Do not enable the management menu by default.