Feed video enclosures are unaffected by CCK RSS display settings

There should be a field setting on the admin page in 3, that has '<hidden>' as an option, as well as an 'exclude' check box. (edited because drupal didn't like hidden in gt/lt)

no, i meant number 3 of your example. http://DOMAIN/admin/content/types/CONTENT-TYPE/display/rss should have <hidden> (which ended up not coming through drupal's filter, sorry). or an exclude check box.

brian,

try checking the 'exclude' checkbox, and selecting 'hidden' from the drop down (that currently reads 'Image Thumbnail' in the screenshot).

I can confirm this problem (which affects our standard em_video field, but not the Flickr Photoset "video" field provided by the Media: Flickr companion module, for whatever that's worth).

I've set our Video field to hidden and checked the exclude checkbox, and it still appears in the RSS feed. And since only the first enclosure "counts" when it comes to podcasting and valid RSS, I can't create an iTunes-compliant podcast that includes a content-type that has video as well as an MP3.

Here is an example of what appears in the feed for a node that has both a populated Embedded Media field and an MP3 in its Filefield:

 <media:content url="http://youtube.com/v/1tzQQO7oN-4" fileSize="988" type="application/x-shockwave-flash"> <media:thumbnail url="http://img.youtube.com/vi/1tzQQO7oN-4/0.jpg" />

</media:content>
 <enclosure url="http://youtube.com/v/1tzQQO7oN-4" length="988" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" />
 <enclosure url="http://SITENAME.COM/sites/nafonline.net/files/sites/SITENAME.COM/files/events/superfusion_mp3.mp3" length="16039393" type="audio/mpeg" />

I even rearranged the fields in the node, but the embedded video enclosure still comes ahead of the filefield enclosure.

Help?

Same problem here, would like to remove the attached files too and can't find a way...
Its in general not easy to define the exact output of what fields should be in the feed...

Suggestions?

Best Regards,
Sandro

I am also experiencing this issue.

I am using embedded video field.
I am producing my feed with Views.
I have set the field to hidden on the display tab and also checked the exclude option (see screenshot)

I am still getting the enclosure in the feed output (see second screenshot)

I thought maybe I could just override a .tpl in views, but when I went looking through the ones in the theme information section I did not see a place where the enclosure is added in the template, so I assume that is happening elsewhere.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

thanks

Totally not a solution that should be used, but I was able to remove the enclosure from my rss by commenting a function in emvideo.module

function emvideo_emfield_rss($node, $items = array(), $teaser = NULL) {
  $rss_data = array();
  foreach ($items as $item) {
    // note only the first $item will get an RSS enclosure, other items may have media: data in the feed however
    if ($item['value'] && $item['provider']) {
      $rss_data[] = module_invoke('emfield', 'include_invoke', 'emvideo', $item['provider'], 'rss', $item, $teaser);
    }
  }

  return $rss_data;
}

to

function emvideo_emfield_rss($node, $items = array(), $teaser = NULL) {
  $rss_data = array();
  foreach ($items as $item) {
    // note only the first $item will get an RSS enclosure, other items may have media: data in the feed however
    if ($item['value'] && $item['provider']) {
      $rss_data[] = module_invoke('emfield', 'include_invoke', 'emvideo', $item['provider'], 'rss', $item, $teaser);
    }
  }

  //return $rss_data;
}

this will only work for the video field and is definitely not best practice, but until I can figure out the way to do this properly I am using this.

I can confirm this is happening using Drupal 6.15, CCK 6.x-2.6, Emfield 6.x-1.18.

Under Content Type -> Display Fields -> RSS, the video field is marked as hidden and excluded, but the media enclosure is still showing up in blog module's RSS feed.

Also, my watchdog was getting the following error every time someone tried to view the feed: "Could not connect to youtube, HTTP error 404"

The hack in comment #10 gets rid of both problems for me (temporary solution).

Subscribing.

Also an issue in 6.x-1.20.

Subscribe

Here is the solution I found that worked for me.

http://drupal.org/project/remove_upload_enclosures

Subscribe

Same problem, Drupal 6.20, Emfield 6.x-2.4. YouTube fields are not affected by the CCK RSS Display settings and will output as an unwanted enclosure in the feed. I think this should be considered a bug?

Changing title, category, version, status accordingly

I'm just wondering if anyone has found a definitive workaround for this issue? I noticed the issue has been open for 1.5 years.

Yeah another year on I have not been able to get the references to the video to go away in the RSS even after setting exclude and hidden on RSS field settings in the content type display settings. :(