Can't get it to work at all!

Glad to see someone else trying to figure this out.

Can you try posting from the email address of user 1, after subscribing that user to the group? I have a suspicion that it only works for user 1.

Otherwise I am having fairly similar behavior - please look at the other issues and try to see similarities with your situation.

Meanwhile, it has been hard getting a response from the maintainer of the mail2og module. He seems to be active but not here.

Thanks,

Tobias

Hi Deggertsen - how did your exploration go? No input forthcoming from maintainer, so we may need to find other ways to get this much needed functionality.

Cheers,

Tobias

Has anyone got this working? - Seems a great idea but no luck getting it to work. Same issues as above

Gordon

Hi gordon.waters - I think we're pretty much stuck until the project maintainer decides to come back to the project, or someone new picks it up. I unfortunately have been unable to reach him.

Email addresses for posting to organic groups is important functionality for Kabissa - something we may be able to raise money for, so if anyone is interested and able to provide this functionality please let me know.

Thanks,

Tobias

Had no luck with this either so still using Messaging+Notifications+MailHandler+Mail2Web+OG_Mailhander (our module here http://drupal.org/project/og_mailhandler) and just setting up a Mailbox and Address per Group - we have this working with certain versions of MNO but not the latest (hence not listing MailComment in the above) - don't think we can offer anything to assist here - so just confirming for others that the other route can be made to work.

I put a note out to the developer's list asking if anyone was interested in taking this over quite some time ago. I unfortunately have zero time to address any of the issues that people are having with this module. I maybe able to look at things early in the new year, but until then unfortunately don't expect anything before then.

G'Day Arthur,

The module addresses a very important usecase for us and for others. It's great that you got the project started. I'm happy to be involved in a bounty process for you if that would help bring some attention back to the project.

Is it possible for you to make a definite indication of your intent to maintain this project, and if so, under what conditions? I'm keen for a production-ready solution within a month (ie, end of Feb).

What are the options?

Kind regards,

JB

Same problem, dont'understand why it doesn't work...

Hi Guillaume - The mail2og project is no longer being developed. Please take a look at http://drupal.org/og_mailinglist which is going to provide much the same functionality and is under active development.

Cheers,

Tobias

This patch fixes a bug that the select values for the mail2og_enabled_groups was not set to the node id. Array merge was renumbering the entire array. Changed it to a simple array addition. Might even be better if the 2 extra values were added to the front of the array. Also, if you happen to have group that is node id 1 then this would be a problem.

@deggertsen, that's why it failed for you. If you choose all groups than it worked with the existing code.

I still didn't get it working with the patch above, but those changes are needed to get that part to work right.

After a little bit of debugging, I found that it came from the query in mail2og_find_email_address() being somewhat messed up. Here's my patch.

It worked for me after applying this.

Okay, so that patch didn't actually do it. This one did!

This issue has been fixed in 6.x-1.0-beta1 and 6.x-2.0-alpha1