This is highly complementary with the Comment CCK module. Not sure why these modules are separate.

Whether I am editing CCK or taxonomy is not important. The feature these two modules are enabling is modification of certain node properties upon comment submissions.

Comments

aren cambre’s picture

aren cambre commented

Related issue: #647150: Merge with Comment alter taxonomy

aclight’s picture

aclight commented
Status: Active » Postponed

Since d.o runs this module for project issues, and since project* doesn't use CCK (see #85049: convert project* to CCK), I don't think it makes sense to merge the modules at the moment.

Also, when comment alter taxonomy was first written, comment_cck made it possible to change the values of cck fields on a node from a comment, but didn't keep any record of how the node was changed by each comment, and therefore also didn't display the change in each comment. Both of these features are required for the way CAT is used in project issues. Maybe comment_cck has changed in the past year or two to support these features, however.

arhak’s picture

arhak commented

subscribe

BenK’s picture

BenK commented

Subscribing....

arhak’s picture

arhak commented

You're welcome to try comment_driven module
which follows a very different approach and is intended to supports taxonomy, cck, as well as node title/body/publishing options/etc
Maintainers of comment_cck comment_alter_taxonomy are very welcome to review/criticize/contribute (as well as co-maintain if desired)

Being the case that maintainers get interested, a migration path would be very nice to have.
Otherwise, please don't think about this new module as an offender.
It was developed without consulting existing module's maintainers due to its totally different approach.
It is not a merge, neither a rewrite of existing modules, just got started as a proof of concept and now seems to deserves its own project space (to which you are more than welcome).