There is a terminology mismatch when using the "Comment: In moderation" filter in the Views admin UI. When you add the filter to a View, it's described as follows:

Comment: In moderation
Whether or not the comment is currently in moderation.

But when you proceed to configure the filter, the option is worded backwards, like this:

Moderated:
o Yes
o No

Question #1, "Is this comment in moderation?" is the opposite of question #2, "Is this comment moderated?" Views presents you with question #2, then interprets your response as if you had answered question #1.

If you choose "Moderated = Yes", you are indicating that you want comments that have been moderated and approved. But Views interprets the "Yes" response to mean "In moderation = Yes", which matches unmoderated/unapproved comments.

The labelling should be consistent and use either "In moderation" or "Moderated" in both places.

Comments

dawehner’s picture

dawehner
Primary language German
commented

Do you want to make a patch out of it? You can help easy to make views better :)

joachim’s picture

joachim commented

This issue could probably be combined with #594402: node and comment moderation UI texts are unclear.

joachim’s picture

joachim commented
Status: Active » Closed (duplicate)

Closing this as a duplicate; patch at the other issue addresses this too.