Community & Support

Seeking WYSIWYG editorwith image upload, not URL link

I have a D6 site with several content types where registered users can create public posts. I am using the WYSIWYG API, currently with TinyMCE. The only feature lacking is the ability to upload images; the only option is to paste in a URL to an image from another website (ie Flickr, etc).

First, my audience is not very sophisticated about computers. Most visitors may not have a Flickr or other account. And the Text editors I have seen that have image upload ability make the user go through a GUI comparable to the Space Shuttle's control panel.

My second issue is with having pages and pages with links to external content. Is that a wise move? If the server the image is on is slow, my page load will be.

I also wonder how having hundreds (or even thousands) of links to external images, most of them being to just a few domains like Flickr, will impact my SEO rankings. Will the search engines see that as some kind of linkback scheme and penalize my site?

I tried using the Insert module as per instructions (also added and enabled Filefield and Imagefield modules) but no "Insert" field type was available. And while the Insert module claims to allow the WYSIWYG module to add image upload capabilities to some of the text editors (TinyMCE is one of the listed ones), there are no instructions for enabling the feature - and it certainly was not enabled automatically. There is another image upload module which also claims to work with WYSIWYG API, but it depends on 4-5 other modules I would need to install. Adding 5 or 6 modules to get images uploaded through my text editor seems like overkill: if I develop by throwing 5 modules at a single problem or feature, with that philosophy my server will quickly roll over and die.

Does anyone know of a simple and clean way to have my text editor upload images to my drupal installation? I don't mind switching editors if it's a relatively clean and low-overhead solution. I am having trouble accepting that this issue has not been addressed and resolved, yet I searched the documentation here very thoroughly and only found one reference.

Maybe I will try the Insert module again; perhaps if I install and enable Insert first, then install WYSIWYG API afterwards, the claimed image upload will be enabled in TinyMCE.

Comments

try out IMCE, there's a

try out IMCE, there's also a bridge for the WYSIWYG module.

try the CKEditor and use

try the CKEditor and use their plugin for CKFinder. It's one of the best editors!
http://drupal.org/project/ckeditor
http://ckfinder.com/

I've reviewed these...

The IMCE interface is good, but it's still too complex for my visitors (think "I can click on an icon, but anything else and I'm lost" as their mindset). I am trying to be as inclusive as possible and want to enable uploading for the least sophisticated users. Just as a chain is only as strong as it's weakest link, a web site is only as universally accessible as it's least sophisticated visitor.

I'm liking the CKEditor more and more. I'll probably go that route. it's the most user-friendly of all the editors available for Drupal.

I'm unclear as to a couple of things:

- Why do most of the editors assume you want to insert a link to a pic on the web somewhere? I hat to sound ignorant, but I can't recall ever posting a link to a pic on the web (I'm know I have, it's just so infrequent that I just can't recall a specific time).

- When I am creating an account and get to the "add your pic" part, there is always a simple "Browse" button: you click 'browse, you find the pic on your hard drive, you select it and you are done. Why do all the editors for Drupal take such a different approach; with several tabs, and "add to the server" option, etc.? I'm sure there is a reason, probably to minimize space on the server, but still...

...

- Why do most of the editors assume you want to insert a link to a pic on the web somewhere? I hat to sound ignorant, but I can't recall ever posting a link to a pic on the web (I'm know I have, it's just so infrequent that I just can't recall a specific time).

This is pretty much the standard behaviour of all forum applications I know, which also includes the ability to upload and attach a file to a post (which could be an image), which the core upload module allows.

Not sure whether you've tried this one in conjunction with the core upload module: http://drupal.org/project/inline

NicEdit

I'm looking into NicEdit: if you use Nicupload and tinker with the code a bit, you can bludgeon NicEdit to upload images to your server rather than to Imageshack. Not sure when I'll find the time to tinker with this, but it's nice to know there is another option.

I use fckeditor and insert

I use fckeditor and insert (compatible with imagecache) with image resize filter to do the trick :) Works quite well :)

- Dragolin

Try nicEdit +

Try nicEdit + imagebrowser.module. Need a couple of works to get it done, though :)

love, light n laughter