Google news has skipped a few of the articles that were supposed to be in the news sitemap. Unfortunately the articles are now too old to be included in the sitemap.

Google webmaster tools is reporting this error

Sitemap errors and warnings
Line Status Details
1 Missing XML tag This required tag is missing. Please add it and resubmit.

Parent tag: urlset
Tag: url
Problem detected on: Jul 12, 2010

Any ideas? It has been working fine up until a week ago.

Comments

rabihs’s picture

Did you find the reason for that, I'm facing this problem on my site.
Thanks

davidw’s picture

I too am having this problem. xmlsitemap is working fine, but googlenews is not.
Funny though, googlenews.xml was working fine yesterday when I submitted it with Google Webmaster Tools.
I have a strange feeling that I botched this sitemap stuff by using Google Webmaster Tools.
Anybody shed some light?
I will go through the documentation again and post my findings.

ephman’s picture

having the same issue... any thoughts?

thanks,
ephman

bmarti44’s picture

I'm thinking it's because we currently do not have any content that was created in the last two days. . . Maybe when there is nothing to put in the sitemap, this error is thrown?

bmarti44’s picture

Confirmed, this is because the sitemap does not have any entries in it. http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/webmasters/Fk2FxkP0-TM

I haven't been able to find a workaround as of yet.

damienmckenna’s picture

Title: Missing XML tag » Don't output anything if no nodes available
Category: bug » feature

Instead might it be better to not output anything if there is nothing to actually output?

damienmckenna’s picture

Version: 6.x-1.4 » 7.x-1.x-dev
Issue summary: View changes
damienmckenna’s picture

Category: Feature request » Bug report

Does the spec require an empty file if no values exist? I couldn't find an answer to this. Thanks.