Closed (fixed)
Project:
Drupal.org Redesign
Component:
Search
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Task
Assigned:
Reporter:
Created:
7 Oct 2010 at 23:09 UTC
Updated:
3 Jan 2014 at 02:04 UTC
Jump to comment: Most recent, Most recent file
Sample URL: http://beta.drupal.org/search/apachesolr_multisitesearch/image%20module
prototype: hhttps://infrastructure.drupal.org/drupal.org-style-guide/prototype/searc...
This is a QA Issue stub for Search Results pages
| Comment | File | Size | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| #11 | 2010-10-17_1921.png | 24.77 KB | pbull |
| #10 | Search_dropdown_Chrome_osx.png | 14.99 KB | lp |
| #10 | Search_dropdown_Opera_osx.png | 15.36 KB | lp |
| #10 | Search_dropdown_Safari_osx.png | 14.15 KB | lp |
| #8 | Refine-your-search.png | 21.57 KB | Amazon |
Comments
Comment #1
Cornelius commentedComment #2
Cornelius commentedthe search engine works at a good performance speed. the results are excellent. all links are working. from the functionality perspective the page is working fine.
but i have some remarks from the design-perspective:
right below the "sort by"-textfield above the search results (it is "order by" in the prototype) there is a search button which is not in the prototype. it took me about a minute to figure out what this button does. then, of course, it's obvious.
if you ask me, i would kick this button out and connect the action of sorting with the drop-down-field behind the "sort by"-textfield. this is much better usability than using a button, because if a person uses the drop down field, a click is saved if the chosen action is done right away and not after having to click another button.
my second remark is the drop down-list "refine your search": in my browser (ff 3.6.10, macbook pro 15') i can see an ugly scroll-down-bar in this drop down list which is unnecessary.
please understand my remarks as personal taste. again, the functionality of the page works fine and the search results are great.
Comment #3
Cornelius commentedComment #4
drummI added some JS to submit the order form when something is chosen from a dropdown, and hid the button.
Please attach a screenshot of the refine search scroll bar.
Sending back for another round of QA.
Comment #5
csevb10 commentedReviewed js implementation on both standard search pages + theme/module search pages and everything new/fixed behaved as expected.
Only issue with the automated/js implementation is that the search-button hiding takes a second to respond (at least for me on FF 3.6). What this means is that the button shows up and then the page text moves up after the button disappears. I don't think there's anything worth worrying about for launch, but it might be worth filing an issue to review after launch and discuss ways to make this a little less clunky feeling.
Right now all elements are drop-downs, but, after launch, we might add additional vocabularies related to themes or modules, etc. If we do that, those elements will display as checkboxes rather than drop-downs. Are things configured to work for checkboxes in the same way that they're set up for the drop-downs?
Comment #6
smx commentedComment #7
smx commentedComment #8
Amazon commentedI tested the new JS search auto submit and it worked.
Here's a screenshot of the 'refine your search' scroll bar issue:
Comment #9
Amazon commentedAssigning to Drumm
Comment #10
lp commentedNote that the 'refine your search' dropdown appears without the scrollbar in some browsers:
Chrome 6.0.472.62 - OS X: Appears as expected
Opera 10.63/Mac - OS X: Appears as expected
Safari 5.0.1 - OS X: Appears as expected
Comment #11
pbull commentedAdding a
overflow:visible;on#search-theme-form-advanced fieldset.collapsible .fieldset-wrapperfixes the dropdown scrollbar issue in OSX/Firefox.There appears to be a z-index issue with the advanced search dropdown in IE7, see attached screenshot (Win XP/IE7).
Comment #12
c4rl commentedSubscribing
Comment #13
drummNow that I added All, it would be ideal to put these in two columns. Is there a better way to do this than shuffling the source order and float: left? We want to keep modules and themes together.
Comment #14
c4rl commented@drumm, I'll investigate. At worst, would be reordered with JS.
Related issue: #935240: QA: Search Box (Home) [Theme]
Comment #15
c4rl commentedTag
Comment #16
drummLets not do JS, rearranging the DOM is slow and we have a server to make the right HTML.
Comment #17
c4rl commentedI got this working purely with CSS -- it uses specific IDs as targets. Will be visible on http://redesign.drupal.org shortly
Comment #18
c4rl commentedNevermind, had some problems in IE. Will update again shortly.
Comment #19
c4rl commentedCommitted this change, currently launch is taking place so this might not be immediately visible.
Comment #20
drumm