Hello,
I am really thankful for "Comment OG" since is doing exactly what I need and it is filling a gap which was ruining the power of Organic Groups.

Due to advanced functionality I need in comments I am forced to move to "Node Comment" for my Drupal 6.19 installation and this is where I lose the benefit of "Comment OG" since it does not seem to prevent non-members from commenting on non-joined group post as I need to do.

So I am asking: do you have any suggestion to have the functionality of "Comment OG" applied to "Node Comment"-type comments?

Or, would the maintainer think it could be doable to extend "Comment OG"'s functionalty to "Node Comment" too?

Searching for (possibly) related issues I found (I need 6.x-based solutions):

Node comments (6.x) » Issues: Organic groups
http://drupal.org/node/743746

Node comments (5.x) » Issues: Compatibility with Organic Groups?
http://drupal.org/node/240471

Organic groups (5.x) » Issues: Compatibility with Nodecomment?
http://drupal.org/node/240474

Any hint or perspective is really, really useful and appreciated: I would love to have quick snippets or patches to make this work during the wait of a possible upgraded "Comment OG".

Thank you.

A.M.

Comments

chromix’s picture

chromix commented

I won't be able to work on this until later this month, but you've made a good case for this feature, and the documentation you've provided is helpful. I'm looking at the critical code for nodecomment, and at first glance it appears that links could be adjusted using hook_link_alter (similar to how it's done now).

Up until now this module has essentially just been an "enable it and you're done" kind of module. With the addition of nodecomment, you're opening up commenting to a wide variety of situations (e.g. "forum_reply" for forums, "comment" for articles, core comments for news pages, etc.) There will have to be additional configuration options once nodecomment is added to the mix, since you may not want the functionality to work on all content types within OG.

That said, I am definitely open to adding support for nodecomment. If you have a chance to try this on your own during the next few weeks go ahead and post your results here.

chromix’s picture

chromix commented
Category: bug » feature

switching to feature request...

YK85’s picture

YK85 commented

Hello,

I was wondering if there may have been any development in this feature?
Great module and thank you!