It would be nice to have a stable release to provide site builders more certainty that the module will get an SA for any security issues. Please feel free to update this issue summary to include links to issues to fix prior to that release.
As of this post, there are 2 critical bugs in the queue:
#1372284: Required field indicated but not enforced
#1559048: Evaluating multi-value dependency arrays fail
#1561272: Conditionally required fields are not required
#1637466: Dependent field is not acted upon with multiple OR/XOR dependees unless last inserted dependee is selected.
#1958000: Edit dependency validation with multi-valued dependency causes data loss
#2021319: Uncaught Type Error: Object 0 has no method 'charAt'
...And there are 8 major bugs:
#1542706: Conditional fields not saving
#1806342: Conditional fields with nested field collections
#1774414: Javascript errors for invalid animation "empty" effect, breaks UI fields from being toggled "visible"; broken UI Assigned to: kevdowney
#1724192: "* is optional when * is filled." Doesn't work
#1154942: Several depends from one field working error
#1489558: Doesn't work with a "Field Collection" on "Profile 2" fields
#1398836: Not working when date is dependee
#1247594: Unable to hide unlimited text fields
You can use the tag D7 stable release blocker to help others identify issues that are blocking a stable release. Currently there are no issues with that tag.
Comments
Comment #1
btopro CreditAttribution: btopro commentedit's also used on over 6k sites in D7, I have a hard time believing it's as unstable as reported on the project page and use in that many (non-production) sites. Any status on even just marking an alpha?
Comment #2
aendra CreditAttribution: aendra commentedSite usage now indicates D7 is almost at parity with the D6 version; why on Earth is there not even a beta stable release yet?
I asked this question on Drupal.SE (http://drupal.stackexchange.com/questions/49270/d7-conditional-field-option) and got a lot of flack, was told "Herpa derpa durr, if yer want a stable version, contribute yerserlf!".
So, to that end, I will contribute code, documentation, WHATEVER IS NEEDED TO GET A STABLE RELEASE -- please, start marking issues with the D7 Stable Release Blocker tag and I'll get on them! But as it is now, it's really hard to tell WTF's up with this module, or how to contribute -- as is probably evidenced by how many "Urr, can I haz Conditional Fieldz yet?" issues in this queue.
I'll start by marking those as duplicate and pointing them at this issue...
Comment #3
greggles@aendrew - I appreciate your passion. It would be great if you could channel it into the 3 critical bugs in the 7.x branch. Once that's done moving on to major bugs makes sense.
I do agree that it would be helpful to testers and site owners alike to create at least a beta release at this point.
Comment #3.0
gregglesnow just 3
Comment #3.1
aendra CreditAttribution: aendra commentedadded list of issues.
Comment #3.2
aendra CreditAttribution: aendra commentedDurr, forgot hash mark.
Comment #4
djbucci CreditAttribution: djbucci commented+1 this. Has there been any major headway made on this since Nov of last year?
Comment #5
Edgar Saumell CreditAttribution: Edgar Saumell commented+1 for a stable release
Comment #6
chaloum CreditAttribution: chaloum commentedOk aren't we heading to the D6 retirement horizon and there isn't a stable D7.
++1 for a stable release
Comment #7
rooby CreditAttribution: rooby commentedPlease make a release of some sort, even if it is just a beta or something.
The reason is that there are bugs being fixed in dev and it makes it much harder to see what version do I have and does it have some fix that was committed on this date.
There are no release notes anywhere to tell people what is being updated/added/fixed because there are no releases.
Plus I have seen other modules snubbing conditional fields integration problems because conditional fields is still in dev.
There are ~14000 users of 7.x-1.x-dev so I think it's safe to say it is stable enough to at lease do a beta or two until the critical issues are resolved.
Comment #7.0
rooby CreditAttribution: rooby commentedNow only 2 crit.
Comment #9
manuelBS CreditAttribution: manuelBS commentedI agree but as I see there is no activity by maintainer any more. Am i wrong? I considered using Field conditional states
Comment #10
hass CreditAttribution: hass commentedThis module is also broken :-(
Comment #11
manuelBS CreditAttribution: manuelBS commentedWhy broken? For me it works great. I greated a patch for feature integration and it works very well.
Comment #12
hass CreditAttribution: hass commentedIt's broken like this module if you have a checkbox that requires other fields; if it checkbox will be enabled.
Comment #13
manuelBS CreditAttribution: manuelBS commentedI suggest to post an issue there, may be it will be patched
Comment #14
hass CreditAttribution: hass commentedAlready done many months ago... a year?
Comment #15
Lios CreditAttribution: Lios commentedGuess this module is never going to happen, is it? Any stable alternatives for a production site?
Comment #16
rooby CreditAttribution: rooby commented@Lios:
https://drupal.org/project/field-conditional-state
Also of note is https://drupal.org/node/1124930
Comment #17
Lios CreditAttribution: Lios commentedNice, but how does that work? I installed the module, turned it on and nothing happens. I don't see where I could add conditions at all (not in contenttype, not in the fields themselves, not in the admin dashboard).
nvm, found it, I always forget to look for tabs (very annoying drupal functionality btw, having menu options on a lot of different places on a page).
Comment #18
rooby CreditAttribution: rooby commentedThere should be an extra tab on the fields page of your content types.
Comment #19
anrikun CreditAttribution: anrikun commented+1 for a stable release, please!
Comment #19.0
anrikun CreditAttribution: anrikun commentedUpdating list of critical issues.
Comment #20
kborowycz CreditAttribution: kborowycz commentedSince the last comment was 4 years ago, is there any plan to do a stable release?
Comment #21
gambryOr at least let's start with a new alpha or beta version #2822513: Release alpha3 .
Comment #22
Chris Matthews CreditAttribution: Chris Matthews commentedConditional Fields 7.x-3.0-alpha2 was released in September 2015. Since then most of the development has been understandably focused on the 8.x branch, which is very much appreciated! However, would it be possible to tag a 7.x-3.0-alpha3 (or -beta1) release in the near future that also includes the current 7.x issues with RTBC status? Additionally, which of the current 7.x issues that needs work and needs review should also be included in this next release?
Comment #23
Chris Matthews CreditAttribution: Chris Matthews commentedComment #24
calefilm CreditAttribution: calefilm as a volunteer commented@Chris 2, thank you.
Support for multiple "Field collection" and "Multifield" fields
https://www.drupal.org/project/conditional_fields/issues/1464950. #341 applied cleanly and seems to work as intended.