Comments not shown after page refresh when the node comment is unpublished

I don't have this problem. Can you explain the setup of the comments? Especially following information:
- Which heartbeat template are you using?
- What is the setting for the comments in that template?
- If you enabled "node comments if in node context", are the node comments enabled as well and which type on the content type?
- is the comment cache enabled in the global heartbeat configuration?

So you comment is not logged in the database as separate heartbeat log, I persume?
So this is completely about the query to heartbeat_comments that is not correct. The comments are not shown by design, since they are hidden by css. Clicking on the "1 comment" or "5 comments" link, would trigger the comment box to open (the comment box AND the list). So you are able to see the comment box since you commented (without nodes, thus in the stream).

That works here. I will try it out some more. Maybe take latest dev, I am working heavily for the moment on heartbeat, so things are changing (for the better).

I wont set this on "cant reproduce" yet, but I 'll need some more info. I see no reason why this should not work. Can you debug in the activitycomments object?

I have the same problem when using Views to display heartbeats. After commenting (activitycomment, not node comment) the comment is shown until the next page refresh. Then the only the number of comments and the comment box is displayed, but not the comments themselves. Also the commentbox is always visible on views, not only if you click the comment button. So I guess this is a problem with the views integration.

The comments are still shown on the build in display pages, no problems there!

I have the same as in #6 however without any inconsistenties.

My setup: install a new drupal with heartbeat (token, rules, display suite, entity, ctools)
Create an article.
Upload my admin avatar.
Visit siteactivity and see two messages. My profile being updated and the node being created.
comment on the profile update message (normal heartbeat comment): works and still shows after refresh.

What is described in #7 could be a views integration bug but imo not the same as the bug reported here. I'll investigate this one as well.

- Edit - So I still need some guidance on how to reproduce this. There must be something totally different in configuration.

I was able to reproduce this as a normal user and played a bit with permissions. Appearantly in the database, the comment I don't see after page refresh, are the ones that are unpublished (or unapproved).
So basically, there is no error, only the end user does not know what just happened. The comment IS logged, only it's not available for everyone.
Two options:
- You do show the comment (special query) and tag this as (you can see this since you commented it, however still under consideration)
- We don't show the comment in both cases, replacing the after comment behavior into "your comment was logged and is waiting moderation..."

Thoughts.

The views problem still to come.

Hey again,

The views problem appears to be the same, leaving me to improve the UX on the not being able to see your own comment.

I added another theme function for the no-comment problem. This way we can alter what we are seeing and even how it's dealt with. You might override this theme function and redelegate to the original so you have the same as before.
However now, you will see something like in screenshot. This is my first and best (for now) solution and thus by design.

All propositions are welcome, but for now, I consider this fixed.
Thx for the report.

I still have problem with this.

I use the standard blocks from the heartbeat module. but the comments are not visible, even though they are listed in the list PUBLISHED HEARTBEAT COMMENTS.

After page reload I can only see the number of comments. Where can I publish/ approve unpublished comments?

When I am adding a node comment, it is shown as expected. but when I add a heartbeat comment, I can only see the author name and the time information but not the comment message. (see screenshot)

so I dont think, that this problem is realy fixed or am I doing something wrong?

I use the standard blocks from the heartbeat module. but the comments are not visible, even though they are listed in the list PUBLISHED HEARTBEAT COMMENTS.
After page reload I can only see the number of comments. Where can I publish/ approve unpublished comments?

Then it seems like you don't have a problem, no? You should see a link "no comments" or "1 comment" where you can click on (like facebook). This should open up the comment box.

Doesn't that work for you?

I can only see the author name and the time information but not the comment message.

Are you sure you using latest dev of heartbeat?

Also this is a total different issue, since the fact that it's about heartbeat comments only, where this ticket is about node context comments only.
I can't really reproduce this, it's all working here. Can you tell us more about your problem and how I could reproduce this from a clean install?

Then it seems like you don't have a problem, no? You should see a link "no comments" or "1 comment" where you can click on (like facebook). This should open up the comment box.

Doesn't that work for you?

no, unfortunately not. as you can see on the image of my last post, the comment block is opened. but the content of the first and the last comments are not shown. these comments were created using the heartbeat comment form. the other two comments, which are shown properly, were created with the standard drupal comment form.

You are using dev? I can see comments that come from heartbeat_comments. I'll try it later on today.

Yes, I am using the dev version.

I did a clean install and everything worked as it should.

But on the other drupal instance with few other modules the problem still exists. i dont know if there is any configuration or module that is interfering.

a little progress:

I commented a Node Creation activity with checked "Enable node comments for this activity template if a node is available". After page refresh I could only see the author name and the time information, but not the content. I checked the database and changed the comment_body_format entry from filtered_html to html and viola the content became visible.

on my web site I removed the fitlered_html input format.

However, when I add a pure heartbeat_comment, that means with unchecked "Enable node comments for this activity template if a node is available" the comment is not shown, even the author name and the time are not shown. only the number of existing comments.

That last remark, that's on the other install? not on the clean install?
I am basically looking for a way to reproduce this behavior to be able to help you.

- Edit - I was able to reproduce it when enabling locale and languages again.

Solution will be to drop translations all together. The way drupal6 worked, that was needed. With the new approach, I'll have to completely get rid of heartbeat_translations.

So, currently it's fixed with latest commit.

The refactoring is started as of now, but this is not the issue here.

I'm interested
Heartbeat irregularities (also called cardiac arrhythmias) arrhythmia is deviations from the normal heart rhythm, steady beating of the heart such you feel an irregular heartbeat at night.
https://treasure4us.com/heartbeat-irregularities/