Problem/Motivation

It is difficult to find uncategorized modules.

Proposed resolution

We have two options:
1. Add “Other” category.
2. Make "Category" field on project nodes required
3. Set all currently uncategorized modules to "Other" via db query magic.

Remaining tasks

Determine the actual number of uncategorized modules to see if this is worth pursuing. Pick one of the two options above and implement it.

Original report by BAMaustin

Due to the small number of 6.x modules, I was able to notice that the Module browse by category did not give access to uncategorized modules.

I was thinking I had been diligent in looking though the categories.... turns out I needed to cross-check through the Alphabetical Listing too! This fact is invisible because there are SO many modules. Plus, the Browse by Name doesn't give a record count and summing up the listings for all the categories wouldn't match the total number of projects anyway (since many project have multiple categories). I only noticed because I build a cross-reference of 6.x module categories trying to locate a 'missing' Admiinstration category record. (See http://drupal.org/node/177981 )

Perhaps there should be just be an "uncategorized" category so they can be reviewed without looking through the entire list?

If you don't want to 'enable' lazy project submission practices, wouldn't making a valid category definition into a "required entry" field be a good idea? Maybe even add a "nag" eMail that gets sent every day/week to the uncategorized project Maintainers saying how many times users had to wade though a Miscellany of undifferentiated modules (how many tmes the uncategorized page was served) because they haven't set their categories yet. If those eMails bounce, perhaps a solicitation should be added to the project description requesting someone take over as Maintainer and the project set to 'inactive' or 'on hiatus' until a new Maintainer steps up.

Perhaps a voting option on whether a project should be re-categorized would be a cool feature. (Weighted by profile level of the voter, of course. Newbies like me always offer unqualified opinions.)

References: User VeryMisunderstood added categories to the 2 modules I noticed had them missing in the 6.x filtered listings. )
http://drupal.org/project/issues/57296
http://drupal.org/project/issues/137538

Comments

VM’s picture

Component: Site organization » Redesign

For some reason I can't add a new comment. As such, I'm editing a comment I had already placed here.

Making the field required makes sense to me. I'd consider a note in the description that if an already existing category doesn't fit the module to select the closest and request a new category with a link to the issue queue. This assumes the field in question isn't a free tagging field.

As far as the 1100 already existing uncategorized modules are concerned. I can certainly aid in categorizing them as I did the two mentioned in the issue summary.

oadaeh’s picture

I was caught by this recently.

Is there any sort of direction and/or guidance on moving this forward?

I would be willing to contact module maintainers via the issue queue to get them to categorize their module, if I were able to get a list of all those that were not.

Also, w/o that field being required, I don't believe this would be a one time occurrence, so getting a list from the database for a one time fix would not be a good idea.

I would even be willing to do the work necessary to get something into place for the future.

lizzjoy’s picture

Component: Redesign » Site organization
Issue summary: View changes

I updated the summary so we can move forward with this issue.

lizzjoy’s picture

The actual number of uncategorized modules is 1100. Perhaps this helps in determining what is next.

tvn’s picture

Issue summary: View changes

Issue summary text format was set to Full HTML preventing people from commenting. Switching back.

tvn’s picture

I added new module category "Other".

I think what we could do now is:
1. Make the field required
2. Set all currently uncategorized modules to "Other" via db query magic.

tvn’s picture

Issue summary: View changes
tvn’s picture

Title: Uncategorized modules category? » Make "Category" field on project nodes required
Project: Drupal.org site moderators » Drupal.org customizations
Version: » 7.x-3.x-dev
Component: Site organization » Code