Closed (won't fix)
Project:
Advanced Forum
Version:
5.x-1.x-dev
Component:
Code
Priority:
Normal
Category:
Feature request
Assigned:
Reporter:
Created:
12 Dec 2007 at 22:35 UTC
Updated:
22 Feb 2008 at 03:58 UTC
My post count tally doesn't correspond to the user title tally. The user title module lets me select what content-type should count towards the title. In the same way, I wish there would be the configurable option to select the content-type to count towards the post count in the post count module.
Comments
Comment #1
michelleI can look into that. That module is from flatforum and I haven't looked at the code. My guess is it wouldn't be hard to do.
Michelle
Comment #2
michelleChanging the title so I remember what this is.
Michelle
Comment #3
jaydub commentedI believe that user_stats module holds promise for helping to provide user stats/profile/etc information. The module is clean and simple and should be able to be dropped right into advanced_forum.
http://drupal.org/project/user_stats and http://drupal.org/node/199089 for configurable content types for the post count.
Comment #4
michelleAs I said in your other comment, I had already looked at this a while ago and decided not to use it. However, your patch for the post counts sounds interesting. I'll take a look at that and see if I can work it in. Of course, anyone is welcome to use user_stats with their forums but I had already done a lot of what's in it before I heard of it and I didn't want to have a dependency on it for advforum.
Michelle
Comment #5
liam mcdermott commentedYou haven't integrated with workflow-ng and Token though. That's really the point of the module (although it doesn't depend upon either of those modules, it just integrates if they're there). :)
Workflow-ng and Token integration means we can do automatic user promotions based on post count and number of days registered/since last post/since last logged-in etc. vBulletin has this feature: my forums used it, which is why user_stats was written.
Also, it's a bit of functionality you can let someone else worry about. Version 1.0 will be released when Jaydub's excellent patch has been committed: http://drupal.org/node/199089 and when we've got some documentation (I'll write it when that patch has been committed).
It's up to you whether you want to integrate user_stats of course, would be great if you did though. :)
Comment #6
michelleLiam,
Yeah, the post count stuff sounds like it's better than what came with flatforum, which is what I used. The trouble is the overlap in the other features. You're module provides:
days registered;
join date;
days since last login;
days since last post;
post count;
user online/offline;
IP address;
Of those, only the post count warrants adding another module since the rest are all really simple things. I'm trying to avoid dependencies as much as possible, so I don't want to just rip out all my code and make it dependent on user_stats. Especially since I'd need to do the same for advprofile (they share code). But what I can do is add in an extra check to see if user_stats is enabled and use that for the post counts if so. Then they'd just leave the post counts submodule unchecked and use yours instead.
Thanks,
Michelle
Comment #7
liam mcdermott commentedJust to quickly explain the reasoning behind those simple additions: integration with workflow-ng and Token. The user promotions based on days registered etc. mentioned in #5. So it's important the module includes this simple stuff. :)
Sounds like an excellent compromise. Thanks very much!
Comment #8
michelleActually, I've changed my mind on this. I really have no desire to port the old flatforum post count module to D6 so I'm just going to drop it and people can use user_stats if they want that functionality.
Michelle