forum / og_forum and nodecomments

As far as I know using nodecomment with og_forum will not work as expected. Nodecomments (and node profiles of any sort) are hacks for developers who want to get views and CCK to do the heavy lifting on comments and profile. They're popular hacks, but they're still hacks. For most people these are going to be dead-end solutions that will probably not have upgrade paths and long term support. I'd see what you can do to get og_forum working like you want it to.

Hi,

Nodeforum is needed when you use node comments is stated somewhere, but nodeforum is not committed and not yet ok.
I have the nodetype working now, but the nodes which are added are not correct placed as forum posts.
May be we can help each other to get nodeforum working!
I attached my 80% working version on: http://drupal.org/node/200871#comment-768735

Nodeforum 1.1 is on CVS: http://cvs.drupal.org/viewvc.py/drupal/contributions/modules/nodeforum/ I changed the last function to get nodetypes popping up. Other things not working yet.
greetings,
Martijn

Hi,

Attached my 90% working version.

Greetings,
Martijn

I don't know if my problem is related - but my nodecomments in regular organic groups (not forum) don't seem to trigger the email notification.

Do you all have this problem too?

http://drupal.org/node/240471

Cheers

Hi Summit !

Do you have a 100% working version ? ;)

Thank you very much

Hi,

Nodeforum is working on www.trekking-world.com.
www.drupal.org/project/nodeforum.

greetings,
Martijn
www.trekking-world.com

hi,

so does node forum work with og_forums. It looks like og_forums has a dependency of forums. If Node Forums is installed, then forums modules shouldn't, right?

Node Comments only works when comments module is not installed. Node comments works with Node Forums but not with regular forums, correct?

What would work best would be if node comments, node forums, and og_forums all worked well together. This would be a killer combo.

Chris

D5 branch is not supported anymore. Closing.
Please reopen if the issue is relevant with Nodecomment 6.x-2 branch.