Steps to replicate on drupal.org as an authenticated user:
1) go to piece of content that allows comments
2) fill out comments fields ==> preview
3) in the top preview, there will be two links to "parent" and "reply"
--jpg attached
the "parent" link points to: http://drupal.org/comment/reply#comment-
the "reply" link points to itself: http://drupal.org/comment/reply/26423
| Comment | File | Size | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| comment-preview.jpg | 16.97 KB | samo |
Comments
Comment #1
samo commentedon my install I am changing this line in comment_preview:
to
Comment #2
moshe weitzman commentedComment #3
(not verified) commentedComment #4
(not verified) commentedComment #5
(not verified) commentedComment #6
Uwe Hermann commentedComment #7
lisa commentedI don't think this bug is fixed. I am using Drupal 4.6.6 and have the same problem as described by samo.
I go to a piece of content that allows comments - for example forum, or story. I fill out the comments fields and click preview. In the top preview, I see links to parent - edit - reply
Parent link points to
?q=comment/reply#comment-which takes me back to the home page.Edit link points to
?q=comment/edit/and clicking it results in the following error messages:Reply link points to
?q=comment/reply/2and takes me to a page where I can write a new reply to the first reply which was only previewed, never saved.It seems that these links should not be visible or at least not active in the preview window.
Can anyone help?
Comment #8
mjolley@buy-hot.com commentedThis is the only comment.module issue I've found that might relate to what I and some others have found. Maybe you guys know whether this is related. There's a problem in comment.module that affects replies to nodes but not replies to other comments. I've posted all my findings here: http://drupal.org/node/63554
Comment #9
stevenpatzPossible related problem is not at ALL descriptive.
Comment #10
mjolley@buy-hot.com commentedSorry, I didn't realize I was changing the title of the whole thing, just my post.
Comment #11
magico commentedThis can be changed in a theme by overriding the comment.tpl.php.
Anyway, I think it's still a bug that should also be checked against HEAD.
Comment #12
stevenpatzI don't see this behavior in my 5.5 install. marking as fixed.
Comment #13
(not verified) commentedAutomatically closed -- issue fixed for two weeks with no activity.