Not to be a "thorn in your side" but the name of this module is highly inconsistent with the rest of Drupal. What I mean by this is nowhere in the community are modules and/or themes referred to as "plugins". While you are free to use any name you feel like, wouldn't it make more sense to use Drupal-friendly "jargon".

My suggestion would be to call it "Module Manager".

Comments

Anonymous’s picture

I will admit, the name has bugged me for quite sometime. (And I'm the one who chose it!) :P Module manager would be more clear if you are wanting to manage modules. I suppose the greatest difficulty I've had is figuring out a name that expresses the ability to manage (install / update / remove) modules and themes.

I suppose now would be an ideal time toss out a few different ideas. (Granted, I'm not even sure if we can change the name. It seems that alot of things would have to be changed. Is there a way to get names changed, or is it a "choose wisely" kind of thing?)

bsherwood’s picture

I am not sure. Honestly, I have never created a module and had it hosted on d.o. Maybe talk to a Drupal admin (Dries, webchick (i think), etc...).

I think updating it on d.o wouldn't be to challenging. The only things I can think of would be the project's node title, URL path and any CVS entries.

Before asking for name suggestions, you might want to see if it can be done first. If so, ask away. I am sticking with "Module Manager"

bsimon’s picture

Module Manager isn't totally accurate, but it sounds good, and it should be close enough to make sense to most users. Obviously, you could also just stretch it out to Module and Theme Manager, which doesn't sound quite so neat. Maybe Upgrade Manager or something like that...

If you decide to change the name, wouldn't it be simpler to start with the Drupal 7 version?

As for the name, I think the problem isn't really with Plugin Manager, it's with Drupal, which doesn't have a clear and clearly-defined name for this category (Drupal.org uses 'Downloads', but that's so general that it will lead to further confusion; and perhaps 'Contributions', but that's even worse)

Anonymous’s picture

How about "Module in Charge of Downloading Contributed Themes and Modules for Use with Drupal" or MiCoDCTaMfUwD for short? ;)

Seriously though, I'm having trouble coming up with any name less than four words that clearly and accurately describes this module.

jabapyth’s picture

Before the drupal security team shut me down and sent me over here ;), I had a module that did much the same thing, called "Installator". I think the name has a nice ring to it....

bsherwood’s picture

Awesome!

Lets name it "MiCoDCTaMfUwD". Who's with me? ;-)

anandi’s picture

I would name it just 'Module Manager', doesn't matter that it can handle themes also. Because naming it 'Module Manager' would make it more popular and accessible to most of drupal users - both for discovering it for the first time through d.o and even for regular using it is more easy when names more expectable. Who cares so much that it can also handle themes, let it be nice surprise, a 'side feature', or even submodule - after all it's primary function is managing modules (at least most of the users want this feature).

I myself found it just by chance, i would never think to search for keyword 'plugin'. So lets rename it to 'Module Manager' and to be faithful to truth include in very beginning of description include clear note that it handles both modules and themes. Maybe 'Theme Manager' submodule would make it more easy to find it for those who are looking for theme manager and more easy to disable theme management feature for those who doesn't need it (i am using my customized themes mostly).

I think making it more popular would contribute to faster module development because of more testing, user input, contributions, and after all maybe even sponsorship.

What others think about this perspective ??

P.S. and for renaming it i think it may be not so easy, because you already have got 'plugin_manager' namespace for it, which reflects even in module url in d.o and i think in many other places. I feel that it can be nescessary to create new module and in old module give clear message that it is discontinued in the favour of the new module with link to new place. Also marking all releases in old module as no longer supported may attract attention of ppl using the current module to get news about new module and upgrade to it. Of course it is just my speculations a user perspective - i don't have any module created and maintained. Strategy for such changes should be figured out from documentation and with advice of developers.

SeanBannister’s picture

I agree the name has to explain what this module does, as Joshua said it install's/update's/remove's modules. While "Module Manager" isn't an incorrect name it's hard to know what this module does just from reading the name.

I do however think "Module Installer" explains the 3 things we want to say install/update/remove. It may not directly say "update" but the process of updating a module is installing a new version so I certainly think it implies it better than "Module Manager".

But anything is better than Plugin Manager :)

bsherwood’s picture

Oh...I like Module Installer better!

Good job Sean!