Is the project ACTIVESELECT still being maintained?

Comments

francewhoa’s picture

Title: Is the project ACTIVESELECT still being maintained? » ACTIVESELECT appears to be abandoned

The maintainer has not responded. Moving the issue to the webmasters queue at http://drupal.org/node/487040

This module might need a co-maintainer or a new maintainer: http://drupal.org/node/251466

A Drupal 6 branch needs to be setup.

Link to project page: http://drupal.org/project/activeselect

Jaza’s picture

Title: ACTIVESELECT appears to be abandoned » New maintainer wanted for Active Select
Status: Active » Needs review

I am the maintainer of active select, however I am not currently actively maintaining the module. The main module that made use of active select was the Category module for Drupal 5 (and Drupal 4.7). Active Select was originally written (for the Category module) for Drupal 4.7, at a time when Drupal core received its first-ever JavaScript libraries, and when things like AJAX were still cutting-edge and immature. However, a lot of things have changed since then. The Category module for Drupal 6 implements its own AJAX drill-down select system (using the built-in AHAH form functionality new to Drupal 6, and based on the book module implementation). As such, the Category module no longer has any need for activeselect.

Additionally, I believe that there are much better ways of implementing AJAX-based select widgets in Drupal 6. In particular, using the #ahah form API property, or using the Hierarchical Select module, are both superior alternatives. I therefore really don't see any reason why I or anyone else should continue to maintain activeselect. However, I could be wrong - there could be other people who believe that this module still has value in the Drupal 6 world, and that it's worth the effort of maintaining.

If anyone is interested in taking over maintainership of this module, please reply in this thread, or contact me directly. Thanks.

dave reid’s picture

@Jaza: FYI If no one offers to help maintain the module and you'd like us to re-assign the module ownership to the 'Abandoned modules' user, file an issue in the webmasters queue.

francewhoa’s picture

Thanks for the update Jaza :)

The information in your above comment #2 is valuable. I suggest adding some of it to the module project page as a note before the module description. And adding link to alternate project(s). And adding that this project is unlikely to be maintained in Drupal 4 & 5. And adding that this project will not be ported to Drupal 6. So users and contributors efforts would be redirected to alternate projects.

Module project page: http://drupal.org/project/activeselect

nancydru’s picture

@Jaza: There are still a lot of D5 sites that are benefiting from this module.

francewhoa’s picture

Indeed. According to the module usage statistic page there is currently 400 or so D5 websites using this module. Source: http://drupal.org/project/usage/activeselect

catapultparlor’s picture

Component: Miscellaneous » Documentation
Category: support » task
Priority: Normal » Minor

Second...

NewZeal’s picture

I have created a D6 version of this project and am using it in another module here: http://drupal.org/project/country_select . A poster has alerted me to possible namespace conflicts or at least breakage of Drupal conventions so I am putting my name forward to be maintainer of this module. The D6 version is working just fine.

vivdrupal’s picture

New Zeal, could you please give a link here to download D6 version of Active Select project that you are using.

Thanks

nancydru’s picture

@New Zeal: Given that the two week waiting period since your off has expired, you can create an issue in the webmaster's queue and reference this issue. They should make you the maintainer with no trouble.

NewZeal’s picture

Hi Nancy,

I've done a search but am unable to find the webmaster queue. Can you give me the url?

Thanks

silverwing’s picture

b2bweb’s picture

subscribing...