Posted by neochief on July 22, 2009 at 1:27am
| Project: | Internationalization |
| Version: | 6.x-1.x-dev |
| Component: | Taxonomy |
| Category: | task |
| Priority: | normal |
| Assigned: | Unassigned |
| Status: | closed (won't fix) |
Issue Summary
In some cases there are no reason to have separate comments for each node translation. This module joins comments from each translations and displays them in one listing. This behavior can be changed on content type basis.
Translation template and Uk+Ru translations included.
| Attachment | Size | Status | Test result | Operations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| i18ncomment.zip | 7.92 KB | Ignored: Check issue status. | None | None |
Comments
#1
Good idea. :)
#2
+1
#3
It's very useful
#4
+1
Thank you!!!
#5
Excellent module. When the inc. in 18n?
Best regards Alexandr Poddubsky.
Когда увидим то?
#6
Thank you for this useful module!
#7
Fixed bug with comments form on separate page.
#8
This is what I was looking for a long time :) But I need (and many people also) it for drupal 5.
Are you planning to backport it?
#9
Nope.
#10
Here's a patch on place of tarball.
#11
+1
#12
Found compatibility bug with Advanced Forum. Because of $node->comment = NULL, AF thinks that forum is locked. Solution is to set 18ncomments' system weight to big number and run it's hooks after others. This patch contains solution.
#13
Thank you, I think it's a long waited solution.
Worth including in the i18n package after testing.
#14
Hi, I'm looking for the opposite! :)
I have a node type with Multilingual support disabled, only labels fields are translated with i18n.
But I need Multilingual support enable for commets. Users could choose the language the comment is writing to. And comments will be show only of the language written.
Any ideas?
#15
&Junro
I am looking for the same thing. Subscribing
#16
@Junro, @mcload, sorry guys, but this not that would be implemented soon. I can suggest you to use Node comment module. THis will allow you to make your comment nodetype translatable and so on.
#17
@neochief
OK, I'm going to look after Node comment module. Thanks :)
#18
This module sounds like an important addition to i18n enabled websites with comments enabled, but I think it's not a module for the i18n package.
It's name may be better if named "Joined multilingual comments". Personally I would rename the module and move it to an extra project. Please do not use this module name to allow i18n to use the 'i18ncomment' name if it would ever implement translatable comments (this is what I expected from the name). i18n module is mainly for translation of multilingual content, not to change functionality of core.
I could be wrong, therefore I'm waiting for Jose to comment on this.
#19
Hello,
anout the nodecomments module:
Nodecomments module doesn't work with i18n, it could be but nobody has provide a patch for it.
see #560442: Multilingual support for comments doesn't work
I just need to display comment in there domain language.
If you write a comment on a sub-domain France, they only have to be display on sub-domain in French Language (France, Quebec, Belgium..).
If you write a comment on a sub-domain Spain, they only have to be display on sub-domain in Spanish Language (Spain, Argentina, Mexico...).
I don't want make comment translable.
So, nodecomments module is useless to me.
ps: "This module will probably consume more resources and run slower than the built-in comment module, so don't use it if performance is a concern."...
#20
Completely agree with @hass in #17
Please, consider creating a new project for it and if so let me know to link it from i18n front page.
#21
Okay, guys, thanks for your feedback. It's okay, I'll move it to a separate module.
#22
Spasibo!
#23
is it real to count this module comments?
#24
For my own custom module, I need to get an array of the comments for a node, but including the comments added to the translation of the node. Now I was wondering if I can re-use something provided by i18ncomments module. I already looked through the code but I am not sure if I can re-use something from there. Could you help me?
#25
+1
#26
+1
Он должен лежать в папке /modules/ или /modules/i18n/ ?
И из какой папки запускать патчи: из той, в которой лежит /i18ncomment/ или в самой /i18ncomment/?
#27
Needed the same functionality, so here you go: little module (but) for D7 - http://drupal.org/project/i18n_comments
Please test and leave comments / bug reports.
#28
awesome module! but it doesnt render all comments (from all node language versions) when i`m trying to output comments thru panels module
as far as i understand i need to add php code like
<?php print($comments); ?>to panels template, but i dont know how to do it.can someone help??
#29
Thanks, good solution!