Deleting a comment does not delete the attached vote.

Thanks, looks like a bug introduced in 1.12 for Drupal 5. I'll have a look.

Oh.. and 6 too. Dang. Problems in both places.

This should now be fixed, you can grab the patch from:

http://cvs.drupal.org/viewvc.py/drupal/contributions/modules/fivestar/fi...

Or wait for 1.13.

How can I manually delete the ratings safely? Either sql or php if the api supports deleting votes.

when the new version comes?

It'll come when the issue queue is cleared of all the current bugs. This issue is fixed, the 1.13 version just hasn't come out yet.

But i have still this problem with drupal6! If i delete the comment the votes are still save in tables and show up in the fivestar

It there any solution for this problem i still have?

2 Years ago i reported this bug, and now i want to use the modul again and this bug is still alive

Drupal 6.17, Fivestar 1.19 :(

This seems to fix the issue. The problem was that in inserts and updates it was using an old data structure so vote_ids were being recorded as "0" in the fivestar table :-S.

Sorry, don't have time to patch against CVS so i just made a patch against the fivestar directory.

The patch seems to have worked, but it doesnt work for existing votes in queue, only new ones..

Furthermore, I think Fivestar should not count a vote until the comment is approved, which it doesnt do now. Votes are counted as soon as they are submitted...

Thanks for the patch, Lewis, I'll try it and see if it works.

By the way, is there any way to manually delete the "orphaned" votes? I tried browsing the database but found no order in the votes - I was unable to find anything that would identify votes that don't have comments assigned. Perhaps I just looked in wrong places?

This patch resolves the issue. Please apply to the patch to the main repository.

Subscribing, thanks for the patch. Hope it gets reviewed by the maintainer and committed soon. Many thanks!

Marked as a duplicate of #601160: Comment-cast ratings not deleted with comment.