Now that Conditional Fields 1.0 is out, we can focus on new features for the next version.

The most common problem with CF is compatibility with non-core CCK modules.
Many patches have been proposed to fix issues with single modules (like Date and Content Taxonomy), but I think that we can't simply add them to the main module, because it would become in brief bloated and unmaintainable.

The best long term solution is to add a plug-in system to CF, so every widget has its own conditional settings that allow it to work. To do this, we need to identify the things that conditional fields needs to know to guarantee compatibility.

My ideas are still not clear on the subject, so contributions – also theoretical – are very welcome.

Comments

peterpoe’s picture

peterpoe CreditAttribution: peterpoe commented

A possible approach was outlined here #227416: Custom conditional fields.

Bilmar’s picture

Bilmar CreditAttribution: Bilmar commented

subscibing - will be available for any future testing if required.
thanks

rburgundy’s picture

rburgundy CreditAttribution: rburgundy commented

+1 subscribing

benone’s picture

benone CreditAttribution: benone commented

+

robby.smith’s picture

robby.smith CreditAttribution: robby.smith commented

+1 this is the last feature stopping me from launching my new website. looking forward to updates

easp’s picture

easp CreditAttribution: easp commented

subscribing

YK85’s picture

YK85 CreditAttribution: YK85 commented

+1 subscribing

capellic’s picture

capellic
he/him/his
Location Austin, Texas
CreditAttribution: capellic commented

For those looking for a solution and for those contemplating how to build it out, some consideration may give given to the Rules module and how it can solve problems. In my case, I had a controlling field to show/hide a Link field and FileField.

The case and solution are here:
http://drupal.org/node/596612

YK85’s picture

YK85 CreditAttribution: YK85 commented

Hello,

I was wondering if all the current compatibility fixes for 2.x is related to the develpment of this plugin system?

Thanks!

peterpoe’s picture

peterpoe CreditAttribution: peterpoe commented

#9: no, they were easy abstractions that do not include any module-specific code. Look what I did for allowed values (copying cck): 

/**
 * Find the allowed values for a field
 */
function conditional_fields_allowed_values($field) {
  $function = $field['module'] .'_allowed_values';
  $options = function_exists($function) ? $function($field) : content_allowed_values($field);
  return $options;
}

This isn't only for Content Taxonomy, but also for any other module that uses the convention MODULE_NAME_allowed_values.

clashar’s picture

clashar CreditAttribution: clashar commented

subscribe

would be super to see the compatibility of Conditional Fields with Multigroup

shopdogg’s picture

shopdogg CreditAttribution: shopdogg commented

subscribe

robby.smith’s picture

robby.smith CreditAttribution: robby.smith commented

hello, I was wondering if there has been any further development in this area?
should we post in drupal module forum for help in this development for conditional fields?
great module and hope to see this module continue to get better!

thanks!

locomo’s picture

locomo CreditAttribution: locomo commented

+1 would love this functionality.. particularly for imagefield

kscheirer’s picture

kscheirer
Primary language English
Location Vallejo
CreditAttribution: kscheirer commented

How about at least adding support for the standard taxonomy module? That seems like a natural for use as a controlling field.

pdevillo’s picture

pdevillo CreditAttribution: pdevillo commented

Support for standard taxonomies as a controlling field would save my day!

pdevillo’s picture

pdevillo CreditAttribution: pdevillo commented

I would love to have the ability to choose values from multiple controlling fields - right now we are limited to one:
example: if field1 value = a and field2 value = c show the conditional field.

YK85’s picture

YK85 CreditAttribution: YK85 commented

Hi Peterpoe,

I was wondering if you have had time to develop the 3.x version you mentioned a few months back?
Really looking for the AND/OR conditional fields support.

Regards

Swipular’s picture

Swipular CreditAttribution: Swipular commented

+1 subscribing

achton’s picture

achton
Location Denmark
CreditAttribution: achton commented

Subscribing too. Any status updates?

davidwhthomas’s picture

davidwhthomas CreditAttribution: davidwhthomas commented

I'm looking for taxonomy / content_taxonomy support, any general thoughts on the process / what would need to change to add this support?
Happy to put together a patch.
DT

kenorb’s picture

kenorb CreditAttribution: kenorb commented

+1

joeysantiago’s picture

joeysantiago CreditAttribution: joeysantiago commented

I'd like to have fields depending on taxonomy terms too... :)

Zuzuesque’s picture

Zuzuesque CreditAttribution: Zuzuesque commented

Taxonomy support would be awsome. I am more than willing to test too, but I am not good enough coding to help much with patches I am afraid.

huba’s picture

huba CreditAttribution: huba commented

subscribing

zet’s picture

zet CreditAttribution: zet commented

+1 for core user Profile registration/edit fields

jonathanmd’s picture

jonathanmd CreditAttribution: jonathanmd commented

+1

fourmi4x’s picture

fourmi4x CreditAttribution: fourmi4x commented

Suscribing, would love to have compatibility with Link module, to solve the "required" problem mentioned here : http://drupal.org/node/549362

fourmi4x’s picture

fourmi4x CreditAttribution: fourmi4x commented

Ok I've found a quick fix for the problem related to the validation of required non-core conditional cck fields.

It works at least for the Link module, but should work for a bunch of other "CCK field modules" too.

There was 2 problems:
- Error when the required conditional field is not visible (condition has not been triggered), asking for filling it in.
- Error when the required conditional field is visible (condition has been triggered), asking for filling it in.
So basically it was not working at all :)

- First problem can be fixed with http://drupal.org/node/919348#comment-4543638
- Second problem can be fixed by modifying the conditional_fields.module file:
In 6.x-2.x-dev, at line 996, add the lines between the comments:

function conditional_fields_check_empty($field) {
  // Normal fields
  if (isset($field[0]['value'])) {
    $value = $field[0]['value'];
  }
  // Node reference
  elseif (isset($field[0]['nid'])) {
    $value = $field[0]['nid'];
  }
  /** add this **/
  // Link module
  elseif (isset($field[0]['url'])) {
    $value = $field[0]['url'];
  }
 /** end add this **/

  if (!count($value) || (is_string($value) && drupal_strlen(trim($value)) == 0)) {
    return TRUE;
  }
...

With these two fixes I finally get a conditional required link field to work!

Encarte’s picture

Encarte CreditAttribution: Encarte commented

subscribe

nclavaud’s picture

nclavaud CreditAttribution: nclavaud commented

same dirty hack for CCK Email Field, works great :

function conditional_fields_check_empty($field) {
  ...
  // Email Field module
  elseif (isset($field[0]['email'])) {
    $value = $field[0]['email'];
  }
  ...
}
Drupa1ish’s picture

Drupa1ish CreditAttribution: Drupa1ish commented
Version: 6.x-2.x-dev » 7.x-3.x-dev
Issue summary: View changes

Version 7.x-3.x-dev works by default with https://drupal.org/project/rolereference and https://drupal.org/project/entityreference ( select list widget tested so far)

kscheirer’s picture

kscheirer
Primary language English
Location Vallejo
CreditAttribution: kscheirer commented

As EuroDomenii mentioned, using 7.x-3x.dev works great with Taxonomy, thanks!

Honza Pobořil’s picture

Honza Pobořil CreditAttribution: Honza Pobořil as a volunteer commented

Is there some guide how to add support for some other widget? Or at least list what should work (to decide if it is for bug report or feature request)?

Honza Pobořil’s picture

Honza Pobořil CreditAttribution: Honza Pobořil as a volunteer commented

Idea: Will be more user friendly if the UI can tell user if this widget is supporter or not.

dqd’s picture

dqd
(formerly "diqidoq")
CreditAttribution: dqd as a volunteer and at MAROQQO studios commented
Status: Active » Closed (outdated)

Thanks for the report and all the efforts in here. But due to inactivity in this issue for some years and because of the upcoming EOL of Drupal 7, I will close this issue on the way by cleaning up the issue queue.

Feel free to re-open as "Needs review" if you found a solution or have a patch to be reported to help others on this outdated version.

If you think this issue or missing feature should be addressed in a newer Drupal core 8 and above compatible version of this project, then please file a new issue to the latest dev.