mail2og seems to interfere with mail2web
tobias - September 25, 2009 - 10:32
| Project: | Mail to OG |
| Version: | 6.x-1.x-dev |
| Component: | Code |
| Category: | bug report |
| Priority: | normal |
| Assigned: | Unassigned |
| Status: | active |
Jump to:
Description
I just discovered that mail2web wasn't working on my site when mail2og was turned on.. when I turned mail2og off it started working again.
I'm not sure what you have in mind in terms of maintaining threaded discussions via mail2og - but I think they are quite important. The way I thought it was going to work is that people can start new topics via mail2og by writing to group_name@foo.com and then discuss them via mail2web by hitting "reply" when they get a notification from eg post@foo.com.
Cheers,
Tobias
#1
can you provide more information on what isn't working- are there any log entries, etc?
#2
Hi Arthur -
Thanks for the quick reply. There are no log entries - it just quietly fails to post the comment to the post. When I turn mail2og module on, mail2web doesn't post comments. when I turn mail2og off again, it works.
I just realized I'm running an older version of mail2web (6.x-1.0-beta2) - I will upgrade it to beta3 and see if that fixes it.
Thanks again,
Tobias
#3
I don't use mail2web, so I'm not really familar with it. My hunch is maybe mail2og thinks that the reply is going to a group. Can you forward me one of the mail2web emails and I'll add some logging to mail2og ?
#4
Just found this issue after running into the same problem as Tobias. What information can we provide to help you track down the underlying issue? You mentioned forwarding you a mail2web email, but I'm not sure if you meant to post it here to the queue, or if you wanted us to actually send it to your email...
thanks!
#5
Hi Arthur -
Let me know how you're getting on with this (and the other issues I posted last week or so) and how I can help. I'm eager to get this production ready and standing by to help as proactively as I can.
Thanks!
Tobias
#6
I am in the same category: mail2web and mail to OG do not play well together. How might I assist in the testing?
#7
I am not sure this is still a problem for me currently - I am able to post as user 1 but not any other user.. even with mail2web is installed. See http://drupal.org/node/585658
-T
#8
whoops - sorry for confusion, but yes indeed there is still a conflict between these two modules. When mail2og is turned on, mail2web does not handle mail.
-T
#9
1++; //subscribing
I have a client request to fix. If anyone has further info, or has this set up in a running dev environment with a debugger, feel free to contact me or post; else I'll be going it on my own...
K
#10
Hi K - How are you getting on with this? I am eager to offer this functionality on my site and would be happy to help with debugging.
Cheers,
Tobias